Search by:
Buffalo Exchange storefront

Buffalo Exchange

2.7(50 reviews)

Address

3862 Fifth Ave, San Diego, California, 92103

Contact & Hours

Hours

Monday11AM-8PM
Tuesday11AM-8PM
Wednesday11AM-8PM
Thursday11AM-8PM
Friday11AM-8PM
Saturday11AM-8PM
Sunday11AM-7PM
Location
Find Buffalo Exchange on the map

Loading map...

In Their Own Words
How Buffalo Exchange describes themselves
Hip chain that buys, sells, trades trendy vintage & used clothing plus accessories for men & women.
Customer Reviews
2.7

50 reviews

5
15
4
3
3
2
2
10
1
20
Misha Prato

Misha Prato

This has been the best buffalo exchange I’ve been to for a plus size girly. Most buffalo exchanges don’t have much XL selection. This one had so many cute clothes!

Owner Response

Hi Misha, we’re so happy to hear you found some gems! Having a size-inclusive inventory is important to us, so we’ll be sure to share your positive feedback with the team. Side note: we’re always looking for great plus size pieces — so if you’ve been meaning to clean out your closet, our buyers would love to take a look! Thanks again and we hope to see you soon!

Daniella Sosa

Daniella Sosa

Always find such great items and they even have a sale rack now with some gems! Selling is super easy I suggest coming once they open it. Every employee I spoke to today was very friendly! Seven took care of going through the items I was selling and I was able to get $30 store credit & I paid $15 for jeans a cute Zara crop top and a lulu trench coat! Such a great deal. Lots of pretty designer dresses as well.

Ashley Hadfield

Ashley Hadfield

If you want to pay $20 for a faded t-shirt with a butterfly on it, this is your place. God i hate this place.

Rick

Rick

Great employees and good clothes. I just wish they would limit people to 50 items or less, if not, they should have an appointment. Some people bring in 200-300 items and the line suddenly goes into a 1 to 2 hour wait.

Melissa Mifsud

Melissa Mifsud

Julianne called me today after I’ve been so desperately looking for my drivers license. Turns out it was in a pair of jeans I sold them and she tracked me down and overnighted it for me. That’s just hands down service. First of all I’ve been selling clothes here for years. Nothing is guaranteed but hey it’s free credit! Thanks for managing with integrity!

Alayna Bone

Alayna Bone

Great staff and selections for everything from costuming to work clothes. I purchased an Anthropologie Maeve button up, Banana Republic blouse, j crew sweater, and the best trousers I’ve ever owned for $100. Everything was in great condition and the store was clean and organized. Will definitely shop here again!

Steph D

Steph D

Love this shop! So many options and sizes. I generally have a small toke finding clothes as I am petite. My partner and I both found great clothes and shoes.

Kara Kubernus

Kara Kubernus

I used to shop at Buffalo when I was in highschool, but had never sold to them prior to my last visit a couple months ago. I had a much better experience than what I expected. Even though I didn't sell as much (I had several trash bags full) as I hoped to, I still walked away with over $100. I was pleasantly surprised by how friendly and sweet the employees were. They bought all my handmade necklaces that I used to sell online but have just been sitting in my room for 15 years because I had a bunch left when I stopped selling. A couple of the girls who worked there even wanted to buy some. I was flattered. The whole "Y2K" aesthetic coming backoKe in style is great because I have even more jewelry I plan on going back to hopefully sell even more because I have a ton and it's getting in my way.

Kelli Gambee

Kelli Gambee

Too bad this doesn't have better reviews because we thought it was fantastic! The prices were good, the selection and sizes perfect! I got a shirt and a pair of comfy shorts. Also, we just had fun taking pics with their fun selection of sunglasses.

Nika Shlopov

Nika Shlopov

great place to get secondhand (and sometimes new clothing)! clothes are about $5-25. if you come to sell clothes, you should call beforehand and ask what they’re looking for because they’re very specific ! they only accept clothes that they need in that season so call beforehand to save time. you can get store credit or cash from what you sell but you get less $$ if you choose cash. overall great store and i always find super cute things <3

Showing 1-10 of 50 reviews
Nearby Antique Stores
Loading nearby stores...