Finders Keepers
Address
141 Boston Post Rd UNIT 3, Old Saybrook, Connecticut, 06475
Loading map...
Finders Keepers is a charming antique store located in Old Saybrook, Connecticut. This store is praised for its "fun" and "interesting" inventory, with one reviewer noting that "it is small but fun, don't forget to check the drawers."
The store's owner, Heidi, is described as "amazing" and "very friendly and helpful," creating a welcoming atmosphere for shoppers. As one customer shared, "Heidi is very friendly and helpful. Stop in and say hi 😊" Another reviewer appreciated the "friendly, helpful" staff and the "great prices," remarking that "the owner was really cool and glad to talk about his interesting overseas heritage."
Finders Keepers offers a diverse array of antique and vintage items, with customers highlighting a wide range of merchandise including "doors, shutters, dishware etc." One shopper was thrilled to find "a tool there that I've been looking for for years, and it's in perfectly serviceable condition." Another noted that there is "new stuff every time I stop bye."
Customers consistently praise the store's "great prices" and "fair" pricing, with one reviewer stating that "this is what thrift stores should be a place where stuff is reused where prices are low enough so that the turn over is quick and mostly everything sells." Another simply declared, "Fun place with great prices!"
Customers have clearly made a lasting impression on this local store. As one enthusiastic reviewer summarized, "So many incredibly wonderful things! So glad I finally stopped in."
26 reviews
Danielle B
I got off the wrong exit and saw a sign for this place and when I passed it I knew it was somewhere I wanted to stop, I even altered my plans to go back before they closed. It is small but fun, don’t for get to check the drawers 😉 Joe was working that day and was wonderful! He even helped me do a recap on the first date I had just had! Overall fun experience and walked away with some cool new to me stuff.
T H
I drive by so often and always see stuff outside but im looking for something certain and although they didnt have it , this place has an a variety of items to look at and prices were decent. Enjoyed looking around and was greeted by someone inside. Had a lot of doors, shutters, dishware etc...
Elizabeth Cook
I was very happy with all the treasures I found today at Finders Keepers. Heidi is very friendly and helpful.Stop in and say hi 😊
Christian Patrick
This is what thrift stores should be a place where stuff is reused where prices are low enough so that the turn over is quick and mostly everything sells. Unlike goodwill where they charge as much as they can and end up just throwing out half the stuff that doesn’t sell or taking it to their outlet stores. Also the owner was really cool and glad to talk about his interesting overseas heritage.
Dan Ryan
Friendly, helpful, lots of stuff! I found a tool there that I've been looking for for years, and it's in perfectly serviceable condition. I couldn't be happier!
Joe Birner
Fun place with great prices! New stuff every time I stop bye. Owner is always kind, fair and honest. 5 stars!!
Cynthia Sigurdson
Heidi is amazing and this is definitely the best place to find the most interesting things!
Lola Colette
So many incredibly wonderful things! So glad I finally stopped in.
Ducky
Super fun and interesting finds! The guy working the counter was very nice and insightful. Definitely worth the trip!
Anthony Ronca
I hallway find bargaining. Friendly atmosphere no pressure to buy price are great. 😀