Search by:
Eyeing the Past storefront

Eyeing the Past

4.8(33 reviews)

Address

1936 Commercial Dr, Fort Myers, Florida, 33901

Contact & Hours

Hours

Monday10AM-4PM
Tuesday11AM-5PM
Wednesday11AM-5PM
Thursday11AM-5PM
Friday11AM-5PM
Saturday11AM-5PM
SundayClosed
Location
Find Eyeing the Past on the map

Loading map...

About This Store

Eyeing the Past: A Treasure Trove of Antiques and Collectibles in Fort Myers, Florida

Eyeing the Past is a multi-dealer antique and collectible shop located in Fort Myers, Florida, offering a diverse array of unique items from over 65 different vendors. Situated across from the popular Edison Mall, this 3,000-square-foot store specializes in an ever-changing inventory of painted furniture, vintage fishing lures, chandeliers, and other one-of-a-kind treasures from the past and present.

Customers consistently praise the store's "beautiful" and "unique" inventory, often discovering "dream" or "amazing" items they didn't expect to find. One reviewer raved about the "stunning" selection of vintage chandeliers, noting that "each one is a work of art." Another customer was thrilled to uncover a collection of "rare and pristine" fishing lures that they had been searching for years to complete their personal collection.

With ample on-site parking and convenient hours from 10am to 5pm, Monday through Saturday, Eyeing the Past makes for an easy and enjoyable shopping experience for both seasoned collectors and casual browsers. Described by customers as a "cute" and "beautiful" space that is "very clean," the store is organized into different vendor stations, allowing visitors to easily navigate the diverse offerings.

Owners Margaret Gartner and Peddy Moran, along with their knowledgeable and friendly staff, are on hand to assist customers and answer any questions. For dealers interested in selling their own antiques and collectibles, vendor space is also available, providing an opportunity to showcase unique finds to a steady stream of enthusiastic shoppers.

Beyond the store's impressive inventory, Eyeing the Past is situated in the heart of Fort Myers, offering visitors a chance to explore the city's vibrant downtown district. Just a short walk away, the historic River District features a variety of local shops, restaurants, and cultural attractions, including the acclaimed Arcade Theatre and the Southwest Florida Museum of History. For those seeking a deeper dive into the region's past, the nearby Edison and Ford Winter Estates provide a fascinating glimpse into the lives and legacies of two of America's most renowned inventors.

Whether you're in search of a one-of-a-kind piece to add to your collection or simply looking to immerse yourself in the charm of the past, a visit to Eyeing the Past in Fort Myers is sure to delight. From rare vintage fishing lures to stunning chandeliers, this antique store has something to captivate every visitor.

Customer Reviews
4.8

33 reviews

5
29
4
3
3
0
2
0
1
1
Janice Magill

Janice Magill

I had great time catching up on news. I found the cutest musical bunny rabbit. Lots of new merchandise.

Elizabeth Carter

Elizabeth Carter

So many special things in this store and the owner was so friendly and personable. I def recommend stopping in.

Olivia S

Olivia S

had the most amazing day here. i came in with my boyfriend, and fell in love with a lamp (my dream lamp!). while i didn’t know, my boyfriend went behind my back and paid for it! all thanks to peddy & him, they surprised me in the sweetest way possible and made my whole entire day. we will absolutely be back here on our antique-only shopping days. 💗

Julissa Melendez

Julissa Melendez

I just discovered this gem the other day and I'm so glad I did! People working here are so pleasant and sweet 😋 I found more than i thought I would. The pricing is more than fair and the vendors have different deals :) will definitely be back !

David Froehlich

David Froehlich

By far the best antique mall we visited in Ft. Meyers, FL. They have actual antiques and many smalls.

Rosa Martinez

Rosa Martinez

Cute place. I bought an adorable dresser here. I am looking forward to going back.

Vicki Cooley

Vicki Cooley

Eyeing the past is a unique and enjoyable experience. There are different vendor stations to sell their items. Margaret Gartner is very knowledgeable about what is for sale in her store. Take the time...walk through the past - you won't regret it!!!

Kurt Nejezchleba

Kurt Nejezchleba

Really cute antiques store with lots of stuff well worth visiting and picking up something for yourself!

Jennifer Martin

Jennifer Martin

What a hidden gem!!! I had no idea they have been there 20 years and why have I not know about this!!! Perfect location, right across from the edison mall and very easy to get in and out! Sooo many cute things I wanted them all but managed to only take what I "needed"!!!

Connie Musselman

Connie Musselman

Absolutely beautiful place. Paddy was so sweet. Loved her. Prices great. Variety was very good. Store very clean. I would go again!!

Showing 1-10 of 33 reviews
Nearby Antique Stores
Loading nearby stores...