It's closed down! Too bad!! It was a great store!

Great place, great selection and the owner is a delight! Make sure you stop in and take a look around!

Beautiful Store lots of Nice Furnishings. Owner is very Knowledgeable and very friendly.

Huge selection! Many nice items to choose.  Owner is very nice and helpful.  Absolutely no pressure to purchase.   Helped bring items to the car.  Highly recommend a visit.

Amazing place to find great unique content for the home, office, or as a Gift.
We found great mid century pieces that really made a difference in our home.

Thee best consignment store and owner in town. Thanks so much Susan!

All the best,
Gator

First time into this amazing establishment - loved the merchandise display and the gentle nature of the shop owner. Will definitely be back

We are so glad you enjoyed your time with us… see you soon

I have found some interesting things here. Lots of great items like huge frames and mirrors and wonderful furniture of all styles. The owner is so nice and the merchandise turns quickly. I never leave empty handed and it’s usually a great find.

Roberto… I’m glad you enjoyed shopping with us.. let us know if our prices are higher then other consignment stores.. bc everything on our floor are negotiable

The owner was very nice and the store was very diverse. The issue was the prices. But she was a very nice lady and dog

Mario it was our absolute pleasure severing you.

Great service , wonderful selection, everything is negotiable , also pet friendly.  Sue is an amazing person.  I definitely stopping by to see the treasures she has in store.  You won’t be disappointed

Susan, great name.. Wink!!! I’m so glad we did a great job for you.. we still have your large items and hop to sell them soon.

Owner Susan Thomas is one of the most responsive, helpful, positive people I’ve ever had the pleasure of working with. She bailed me out of a “near emergency” situation when I HAD to have several very large dining room pieces removed from my new home before movers showed up with others. She jumped through such hoops to help, INCLUDING first connecting me with someone who might have bought directly, and she did NOT want any commission if that had worked out. She arranged for her “moving guy” (they were great too!) to be there asap, and crisis averted! I would also recommend Another Man’s Treasure as just an amazing place to browse; such fascinating and lovely things!

Julie, I’m so glad you where pleased with us.. we aim to give our customers the very best experience.. see you soon😊

If your into consignment shopping this is the place . It is full of great finds at the correct price . I have be been all over Naples and not only is this great place reasonably priced, they are very accommodating !!!! Don't waste your time with the consignments around 5th they are ridiculously overpriced !!!

Gayle, I hope your doing well.. Thank you so much for your review. See you soon.

Since buying a second home in the Fort Myers area I’ve been frequenting consignment shops throughout the Southwest Florida area. I had such wonderful service at Another Man’s Treasure and a willingness to actually work with me on price. I can’t tell you how many places I visited that absolutely wouldn’t budge on price—not even $20, which is ridiculous. I have an entire house to furnish and am looking for good pieces for a reasonable price for second-hand stuff. Susan was awesome to work with. Although the store is a bit crowded, there was so much to look at and I was happy to find a small desk and chair and a home decor item that fit perfectly with what I was looking for. She also moved the pieces into my car. She was so friendly and accommodating and I really appreciated that. Some other stores I didn’t get that reception at all. I highly recommend checking out this store if you’re looking for a variety of items, friendly service, and a willingness to negotiate pricing.

T.R, we are so delighted that you took your time to give us a review.. Thank you .

This place is well organized and has so many beautiful pieces in great condition. The owner, Susan, was so kind and helpful!

Scott, Thank you so much for taking the time to give us a review.. See you soon.

Really cute eclectic store. Knick knacks to nice furniture. Have fun exploring! Friendly service couldn't have been better. We will be back

Carla, it’s was my absolute pleasure to serve you.See you soon.

I had a tricky design problem to solve. Susan found the PERFECT set up as we played around with design ideas and brainstormed together. I loved working with her, and am SO happy with the result, I can't stop glowing about my new couch, table, lamp, and overall newness! I highly recommend Another MANS Treasure.

We are so happy that you enjoyed your time with us.. Thank you so much for your support.

I like going there sometimes just to look around, and there is always something (or several things!) to fall in love with. The owner is upbeat, friendly and easy-going. There are many interesting items to accent your home decor. The prices sometimes may seem a little high, but the owner is always willing to "talk turkey", and I've never had buyer's remorse shopping there. Definitely worth checking out!

J....it was our absolute pleasure having you and your beautiful family visit us. Enjoy you record player and phone,two amazing treasure finds..

The owner is super sweet and has an incredibly bubbly personality and if you were having a bad day just go there and visit she will put a smile on your face....... she has a lot of neat things in the store and the prices are very negotiable and very reasonable.....Ending up scoring a couple really nice antiques for pennies on the dollar.....Go there and visit no telling what you will find

Jon,Thank you for taking the time to give us your review. We will be here when your ready, with great items for you to choose from.

Staff here is amazing! Super friendly and helpful. Inventory is high quality and uniquely varied. Will be my first visit if I need furniture again.

Noelle, we are super excited that our store has given you such a great experience.. See you soon.

Susan is so charming and helpful.  She has an amazing selection of things to chose from.  She greeted us with a smile and and had great ideas and suggestions for what we were looking for.  I highly recommend you take some time to visit this store if you are looking for furniture or decorating ideas.

Pat, we are always happy to help our customers. See you soon.

Went in to Another Man’s Treasures just to look around and immediately found something awesome. Went again and found a gorgeous white couch! Susan was very helpful... provided me with a name of a reliable mover, and even let me store the couch in her garage for a week. She has been very helpful and friendly ever time I’ve interacted with her. Would highly recommend her shop!

SHANKIE, super excited to read your review.. I’m so glad you loved your experience with us.. See you soon.

Great shopping experience. Owner, Susan's energy and flair for design makes for a very interesting place to shop. Large store with lots of variety--lamps, rugs, ottomans, tables, art, etc etc. Found the perfect piece for our home office. And a super cute dog to top it off!!

Renee, it was so nice to read your review.. Thank you so much for taking the time to share your experience with us.. See you soon.

absolutely amazing! The store is gorgeous and Susan is a absolute sweetheart! She was so helpful and friendly. I would definitely recommend coming here.

Susan the owner is incredible and always a pleasure to see! Her store has so many options and unique pieces.

Diana, looking forward to seeing you again.

We were fortunate to find this great consignment shop while wintering in Naples, Fl.  They shop is chuck full of great finds in styles to suit various tastes and design.  Products were all in good condition,  The owner was on site and had a very good design eye.  She helped us to select a lovely contemporary, handmade metal fish sculpture that will be used to fill in an empty space in our kitchen.  I will post a picture of it when it is home and in its place of honor.  I highly recommend a visit to Another Mans Treasures!

Thank you so much, It was my pleasure serving you both.

What a surprise... lots of great collectables with a wide variety of choice. Susan is delightful to work, she made the perfect suggestions and went out of her way to source the right frames for our pictures. Can't wait to get back and find more Treasures for our home.

Martha, it was our pleasure seeing you and sharing ideas.. See you soon.

Love this store!  The owner has wonderful furniture and is an interior designer. Such good taste!

Another mans treasure is an absolute gem! Susan has an incredible collection of pieces that is ever changing! So there are always new pieces to discover and fall in love with.

The store is thoughtfully organized and styled, which really inspires and gives you an idea of how pieces fit and work together. This is a true testament to how talented Susan is.

On top of the amazing selection Sufism herself is a joy to work with. She is super knowledgeable and makes you feel right at home. I can’t recommend her incredible store enough. It is a must visit!

Susan's expertise and lovely inventory totally transformed a property that I listed for sale. Four rooms were painted and staged,  and unique items were added to other rooms, which maximized the appearance and all eyes were on it. I recommend her highly. Mary Horesco PA, Realtor.  Naples

The store is beautifully kept. The inventory is quite amazing. A little bit of everything for every taste. The staff was really nice, kind and helpful. I will be back soon. God bless.🙏🙏🙏

Eclectic collection creatively displayed by friendly owner. This place could keep consignment shoppers busy for hours. The quality of the items, from furniture to home accessories, is obvious.

We had a great experience.  LOTS of inventory and so easy to deal with.  We ended up purchasing a leather chair.  Good quality consignment merchandise.

I am a Consignment Store Guru...especially in Naples for the past 10 years.  I am also a decorator.  This is the best place by far...not only do I find fabulous things here, but the prices are really great!  Try this place...you won't be disappointed!!

Wonderful range of items.Well presented. Suzanne could not have been more helpful. We will be back. Bought 5 quality items at great prices and delighted with them all .😃

Phenomenal consignment store probably one of the best in Naples. Came to the store customer service was excellent found a gorgeous picture got it for next to nothing and I appreciate the store the ambience and the furniture. A must visit

From the first time I set foot in Another Mans Treasures ( it was on 10th downtown!) I have never been disappointed. The merchandice is high end and very unique. The staff is very friendly, professional and always willing to help you find whatever you need.  If they don't have it one week, stop back and try again....you WILL find it!!  They are also more than happy to make a deal so you can take your treasure home and enjoy it.  If you happen to change your style, consign that piece you enjoyed and let them sell it for you...every body wins!!  One great store...we got a $ 1500 Pottery Barn king headboard ( used as a staging piece) for $300.  You will never get a bargain like that at a box store...

Thanks for your help guys

What a great place to shop. Suzanne is so professional, welcoming and willing to work out a price. The place is very attractive and well put together.

I LOVE coming here! There is always sometime new that I have to have each time I walk in. Last time it was a crystal bowl that matched my grandmothers set! You never know what you're going to find!

What an amazing store!  I absolutely LOVE what the new owners have done and their eclectic style and professionalism.  If you haven't been here in a while it's time to stop in again and give this store a good walk through.  Be ready to spend some time as there is just a ton of fun things to see.  Prices are good and everything is displayed amazingly.  I really Really enjoyed my shopping trip here.

The new ownership is extraordinary. A professional who is certified interior designer with years of experience. There is such an eclectic selection of furnishings.  Be prepared to spend some time to find all of the treasures.

Great store full of interesting and quality finds. Hidden in the Plaza on 41 and I just noticed it last week. Should check it out

When you close, change your sign from open to close

Fran…… see you on your 5th visit 😀

Wish I could tell you about my shopping experience. The last 4 out of 4 times that I went during “business hours “ they were closed because he was out to an appointment. Put your flags and sandwich sigh away!

This store has so many lovely things, but overpriced.  I enjoy antiquing, however on the couple of occasions I was there, I had to leave due to the loud and annoying music.

Not open, despite the neon open sign on at all times. We went by 3 times while in town and its was never open. Neighboring businesses also confirmed that it is never actually open. Shame because the inventory looks fun

they say they are open but doors are all locked and no one is there. this has happened to me twice

Arrived during open hours but it was closed.  The signs all said open....

Tried to go in at 3:30 on Tuesday and they had doors locked! Open signs on but not open , their hours stated 5pm. Big turn off to an out of towner

Sorry to hear about that... we are under new management and the owner has relocated to St Andrew square, with a second store in Marco island...

Very unprofessional owner.  I was contacted about something I had for sale online.  After several calls working out the details (while I was at work), movers were arranged (by them) for the following day.  I had someone rearrange their schedule to be at my house during the designated time window.  When no movers showed up, I called to find out what was happening.  I received a call back informing me their buyer had changed their mind that morning & so the owner no longer wanted it.  I questioned this as they had told me regardless of whether their buyer wanted it or not, they would still take it. It didn't matter. They didn't even feel it necessary to contact me to let me know.  Not only had they wasted my time, but I had taken apart the piece of furniture in preparation for the movers.  I feel sorry for the person I dealt with on the phone (not the owner) because she apparently left him to make the call & handle it.  A person has a right to change their mind, but the lack of communication is extremely unprofessional.  If this is their level of customer service, they won't be in business long.

This was the worst experience I have ever had!  I had scheduled a time to have all of my  furniture to be picked up three days before I needed to be moved out of my 3 bedroom condo. The day of the "pick up" I had left work to be there and after waiting  30 minutes of the arrival time no one had shown up. I called and was informed that the owner/ manager was going to check on the status of his movers and call me back in 20 to 30 minutes. One hour went by and I called again. The number went directly to voicemail. By this time I went back to work and then had called again from a different number and finally got an answer. I was then told his crew was backed up and that he would call me first thing in the morning. The next morning came and I called him. There was no answer. I called around noon and finally he answers and then tells me that they are too backed up to look for someone else to do it.

I wish I had known that Another Man's Treasure was managed this poorly. I never would have called them. Moving is stressful enough. Thanks for the added stress.

Another Mans Treasures

Hours

Cheryl Johnson

Meredith C

Mike Dirks

Kenny Bookman

Havanna Cafe

R M

Denise Slifer

Shannon Cape

Roberto Rojas

Mario Rodriguez