Butter Curated Thrift
Address
6625 Superior Ave, Sarasota, Florida, 34231
Phone
+1 941-402-4751Loading map...
Butter Curated Thrift is a unique thrift store located in Sarasota, Florida that has captured the hearts of local shoppers. This charming store has built a loyal following through word-of-mouth and exceptional customer experiences.
According to reviews, the store is described as having a "great eye for trinket items" and an "eclectic vibe" with "so many treasures" and "nicely curated items." Customers rave about the "incredible find" of this "new Sarasota staple," praising the "awesome items" and "affordable" prices.
What truly sets Butter Curated Thrift apart is the warm and welcoming atmosphere cultivated by the owners. Reviewers describe the owners as "amazing people" who are "wonderful and nice to talk with" and have "an awesome personality." One customer even noted that the owner's husband was a "delight" to chat with about the store's design and the owner's own artistic creations.
Beyond the merchandise, customers appreciate the store's inclusive spirit, with one reviewer highlighting the sale of pins benefiting the Trevor Project. This inclusive environment, combined with the owners' evident passion for their business, creates a shopping experience that is both enjoyable and meaningful for the Sarasota community.
The overwhelmingly positive reviews suggest that Butter Curated Thrift is a hidden gem worth discovering. As one customer eloquently stated, "This place was warm, welcoming, affordable, and just plain COOL." For those seeking a unique and personalized thrifting experience in Sarasota, Butter Curated Thrift is a must-visit destination.
50 reviews
Shana Foster
Absolutely loved this thrift store! The owners are amazing people and they have a great eye for trinket items. My girlfriend and I were so impressed with the variety and intentional design of the store.
Omgosh Shana, you making us blush! Thanks for the stars and all the love and we hope to see you soon!
Harlace
First time in, loved the place! Friendly owner, inclusive space with pins being sold to benefit the Trevor Project, nicely curated items. Bought a pink panther/henry mancini record and a my little pony mug myself! Would gladly go back
Hey Harlace! Thank you for the stars. We’re so very happy that you found some treasures. We hope to see you again soon! x, Butter
Kira ozmon
Such a cool place ran by such a cool woman. 10/10 experience every time I visit (:
Hey Kira! Thank you so much for the stars and love!
Brian Craft
What an incredible find! There are so many treasures and such an eclectic vibe! I can't wait to come back soon, such an inviting environment and definitely something for everyone, a new Sarasota Staple for sure!
Thanks for the love and the stars Brian! It was super nice to meet you. Looking forward to having you back at Butter! 💛
kirk d
Great little thrift store. The owner, Lili is onsite. She is wonderful and nice to talk with. She has an awesome personality.
Hey Thanks Kirk! That is such a sweet compliment. 🥰 I was super happy to have met you and so glad that you liked the shop! x, Butter
Trinity Treft
Amazing little thrift store with awesome items. Honestly the owner of the shop is what made the entire experience over the top. I loved hearing about the travel finds brought back to the shop. 10/10
Omgosh Trinity! Thanks from the bottom of my heart. You guys were so fun! Thanks for the stars and the love. x, Butter 🥰
Sandra Poore
So many nice things and really good prices. Will definitely be back!
Sandra, we can’t wait to see you again! Thanks for the love and stars. x, Butter
Amii Cures
Loved the environment and space, Chris is so sweet and filled with occasional jokes that makes you laugh, he gave me this pink brochure that says “Guide to Consignment Shops” within Sarasota/Lakewood Ranch and Bradenton! I bought so many beautiful pieces for great prices. I’m sad I never discovered this place sooner and I’m definitely recommending this place to everyone that I know. One of the best gems I’ve come across since living in Sarasota. ♥️
Amii! We’re so stoked you found us! Glad you found some treasures and that you liked the Dad jokes. Be warned, he has an encyclopedia sized book of them. 😜 Thanks for the love and stars. Love, Butter
Kelly Balcom
What a great shop! The owner is fantastic!
Thank you Kelly! We’re so happy you enjoyed our little shop. Love, Butter
Deborah Harding
When I first walked into this store, I was greeted by a myriad of what appeared to be very lovingly curated treasures. I was astonished at how affordable everything was, and quite frankly adored every piece in the store. Everything was just beautiful, and as someone that has visited hundreds of thrift shops a cross the country, it’s one of my favorites. I spoke to the owner’s husband who was a delight. We chatted about basically how cool his wife must be to design this lovely place, and she even had a few of her own artful creations I purchased. This place was warm, welcoming, affordable, and just plain COOL. The pride flags made me feel really good too - as someone within the community there’s something safe seeing a pride flag, knowing the person here may or may not even be in the community, but cares about the rights of people to love who they love, and who they were born to be. Those are my kinda peeps. ENJOY THIS LOVELY STORE! I’ll be back.
Dear Deborah! We are always delighted when our guests like our inventory and prices and vibe. However, what’s more important to us is that people feel included, loved, and safe when they are at Butter. Thank you so much for the kind words and the love. Hope to see you soon! x, Butter #LoveIsLove