Search by:
Cotter Pin Cellar storefront

Cotter Pin Cellar

4.8(5 reviews)

Address

1500 E McCarty St, Jefferson City, Missouri, 65101

Contact & Hours
MondayClosed
TuesdayClosed
Wednesday10AM-5:30PM
Thursday10AM-5:30PM
Friday10AM-5:30PM
Saturday10AM-4PM
Sunday12-4PM
Location
Find Cotter Pin Cellar on the map

Loading map...

About This Store

Cotter Pin Cellar is a premier antique and vintage store located in the vibrant city of Jefferson City, Missouri. Specializing in an extensive collection of Fiesta Dinnerware, farmhouse decor, and a constantly evolving assortment of unique antique finds, this store is a must-visit destination for collectors and decor enthusiasts alike.

The store's Fiesta Dinnerware selection is unparalleled in the Mid-Missouri region, boasting an impressive array of vibrant colors and patterns that cater to every collector's preference. Beyond the Fiesta collection, Cotter Pin Cellar also offers a fantastic array of farmhouse-inspired pieces, including rustic bread boards, dough bowls, and repurposed furniture. Customers can even find Amy Howard One-Step Paint products, perfect for DIY furniture refinishing projects. The store's bridal and gift registries make it a one-stop-shop for those seeking Fiesta Dinnerware and other special occasion gifts.

Situated at 1500 E McCarty St, Cotter Pin Cellar is open Wednesday through Friday from 10 AM to 5:30 PM, Saturday from 10 AM to 4 PM, and Sunday from 12 PM to 4 PM, ensuring ample time for customers to explore the ever-evolving inventory. Conveniently located, the store offers on-site wheelchair-accessible parking, making it easily accessible for all visitors.

Customers consistently praise Cotter Pin Cellar for its exceptional selection of unique and interesting items, as well as the store's reasonable prices. The owner and staff have earned a reputation for their exceptional friendliness and helpfulness, with one customer describing the staff as "incredibly sweet, friendly, and knowledgeable." Another reviewer raved about the owner's "A+ on friendliness and helpfulness," ensuring that each visit to Cotter Pin Cellar is a delightful experience.

Beyond the store's impressive inventory, Cotter Pin Cellar is situated in the heart of Jefferson City, providing easy access to a wealth of local attractions and activities. Visitors can explore the Missouri State Capitol building, just a short distance from the store, or stroll through the scenic Capitol Gardens. The nearby Missouri State Penitentiary offers a fascinating glimpse into the state's history, while the Katy Trail State Park provides ample opportunities for outdoor recreation and scenic views.

Whether you're a seasoned Fiesta Dinnerware collector, a farmhouse decor enthusiast, or simply someone in search of one-of-a-kind vintage finds, Cotter Pin Cellar is a true gem in the heart of Jefferson City. Discover the store's ever-changing inventory, engage with the friendly and knowledgeable staff, and immerse yourself in the vibrant local culture that makes this destination so special.

Customer Reviews
4.8

5 reviews

5
4
4
1
3
0
2
0
1
0
Pauline McElroy

Pauline McElroy

If you like to decorate with bunnies for Easter, this is the place to go. Cute bunnies of every size absolutely delight your senses. Lovely and unique decorations. Owner of the shop is Aplus on friendliness and helpfulness.

Owner Response

Thank you for the kind words. Look forward to seeing you again.

Linda Armstrong

Linda Armstrong

Lots of neat items. Will definitely visit again.

Owner Response

Thank you for the kind words. Look forward to seeing you again.

Diana Stafos

Diana Stafos

A coworker mentioned this business, so I and 6 friends visited on a Saturday. It's a diamond in the rough. Both new and antique items for any decor. Yes, it's a large Fiesta dishware supplier. Prices are very reasonable. They offer a variety of can and spray paint for DIY projects in a wide range of colors and one-coat products. If you're looking to add to or change your decor, you'll be hard pressed not to find items or at least inspiration. The woman working there is incredibly sweet, friendly, and knowledgeable. Ask her anything and be sure to look at everything.

Owner Response

Thank you for the five star rating and visit to our shop. Please come back to see us.

Sharon Fischer

Sharon Fischer

Great little shop clean, neat and wonderful items. Great customer friendly service!

Owner Response

Thank you for visiting our shop and leaving the 5 star rating. Look forward to seeing you again.

Douglas Nentwig

Douglas Nentwig

The person was very helpful

Owner Response

Thank you for stopping by our store. Have a great day.

Nearby Antique Stores
Loading nearby stores...