The Surprise Shop
Hours
Loading map...
The Surprise Shop is a longstanding antique and collectible store located in Sullivan, Missouri. Established over three decades ago, this family-owned business has amassed an impressive inventory spanning a diverse range of vintage items, from classic vinyl records and retro video games to coveted Funko Pop figurines and sought-after Magic: The Gathering cards.
Housed in a larger, more open location, the store now offers an even more inviting and nostalgic shopping experience for its loyal customers. The knowledgeable, friendly owner and staff create a warm, welcoming atmosphere, going above and beyond to help visitors feel at ease as they browse the store's extensive collection. "The staff is incredibly helpful and passionate about their inventory," notes one customer. "They took the time to educate me on the history and value of the items I was interested in."
The Surprise Shop's inventory is a true delight for antique and collectible enthusiasts. Visitors can expect to find an amazing selection of vintage treasures, from beloved childhood favorites like Pokémon, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, and Barbie dolls to rare and hard-to-find items across a wide range of categories. "I was amazed by the sheer variety of items they had in stock," shares another customer. "It was like stepping back in time, with something new and fascinating to discover around every corner."
The store also offers a range of convenient services, including cash, credit, debit, and mobile payments, as well as wheelchair accessibility. Open Monday through Saturday from 9 AM to 5 PM, The Surprise Shop provides ample opportunity for visitors to explore its nostalgic charms.
Situated in the charming town of Sullivan, Missouri, The Surprise Shop is just a short drive from several popular local attractions, including the Meramec Caverns, a renowned natural wonder featuring stunning underground formations and a rich history dating back to the 19th century. Visitors can also explore the town's vibrant downtown area, filled with quaint shops, local eateries, and a thriving arts scene.
Whether you're a seasoned collector or simply someone who appreciates the allure of vintage treasures, a visit to The Surprise Shop is sure to delight and surprise you. With its unparalleled inventory, knowledgeable staff, and inviting atmosphere, this beloved antique store offers a truly unique shopping experience that celebrates the charm and nostalgia of the past.
50 reviews
Tammy Portner
Love visiting the store and finding stuff from your childhood. Very nice new store and the owners are very nice. Definitely a memory lane store. Love it.
Scarlett Cooper
If you love all things vintage and collectibles then this is the place for you! Every decade represented. Records, CDs, Wii, PS, Pokemon, Magic the Gathering, TMNT, Barbie, Funko Pops and more. If you are searching for that hard to find item that represents your childhood… It’s here. The owner is so knowledgeable and friendly.
Taylor Smith
It’s always fun to visit this place, especially now that it got moved to the old “piece of mind” shop - so now it’s gotten a lot bigger and there’s a lot more things to look at and explore
Dayton Killeen
Absolutely awesome shop and nothing even close to it in the surrounding area! Would highly recommend stopping by and looking at what all they have! Good prices and some product you don’t see every day!
Ash Hudson
Love how the new shop looks. It is more open and spacious. Keep up the amazing work and I will most definitely be coming back to shop.
cassie duemler
Absolutely love how I can walk in to a place and feel right at home always inviting and have an ever abundance of stuff to look at even made my 5 yr Olds day highly recommend
We love it when we get this kind of feedback. Thank you!
Lynn Huck
Great prices, fantastic shop. Reasonable prices and helpful owner/employees. Purchased a PS3 for my daughter at an amazing price. Works great!
We really appreciate that feedback.
Keith Bryan
I absolutely love this local Surprise Shop! It's become a special spot for me and my daughter to visit together. From the moment we step inside, we're always greeted with the warmest atmosphere and an incredible variety of unique and fun items. There's something for everyone, whether it's a sweet little trinket or a fun surprise we never expected to find. My daughter always leaves with a huge smile, and I can't wait for our next visit. The staff is so friendly, and they always make us feel right at home. If you're looking for a fun, family-friendly place to explore, this shop is a must! Highly recommend!
We really appreciate your review! It's always a pleasure to hear positive feedback.
Randy Neville
I been in there several times and and was amazing every time lots to see ever time my friends and I say we need to come back to see it all just to take in what we just seen
Hearing positive responses like yours is always encouraging. Thanks!
Rachel Ryno
The workers were very nice and they had a lot of amazing stuff! Very giftable items as well!
Thanks for that great review. We feel like we've got the best customers in the world and clients like you make this work fun and meaningful for us.