Old & New Thrift Shop
Loading map...
Old & New Thrift Shop in Manahawkin, New Jersey appears to be a well-loved and highly regarded thrift store in the local community. The positive customer reviews paint a vivid picture of the store's unique offerings and atmosphere.
According to the reviews, the store is praised for its cleanliness, organization, and the hard work of its volunteer staff. One reviewer noted that the store "looks like a new store" and has "cleared floor space and moved some things around, making it easier to move around" and "actually appears brighter." This suggests the store makes an effort to maintain a pleasant, welcoming shopping environment for its customers.
The inventory at Old & New Thrift Shop seems to be a major draw, with reviewers describing it as having "amazing things" and "good stuff" at "very fair" prices. One customer exclaimed, "I love Love LOVE this Thrift shop. It's so clean and well organized. The volunteers work so hard and it shows! I always find amazing things here!" Another stated, "Great place. Good stuff. Always new things there for cheap."
Customers also consistently praise the friendly, helpful staff at the store. One reviewer shared, "Ruth the cashier was So nice and informative! She made our first experience wonderful." Another noted, "The manager, Maddie, is wonderful and always goes out of her way to be kind to me and my children." The staff's dedication and customer service appear to be a significant part of the store's appeal.
While the store does have strict closing hours, with one reviewer warning "they are very serious about leaving at 2:30. Don't get there at 2:25 thinking you can go shopping," the overall sentiment from customers is overwhelmingly positive. As one reviewer eloquently stated, "I absolutely love the shop..my finds are amazing! The work that goes into taking in the donations, sorting, cleaning, pricing and then put out for shopping, the work is endless and when I learned it was all done by volunteers, my respect for them had risen to higher levels."
50 reviews
Christian Pezzuti
I love the store, but I feel that a thrift store that does not hold any hours in weekends (at least on Saturdays for a bit) is doing itself a disservice.
Judy Bouton
It's a great way to donate items you no longer need and then find new treasures. Always fun to visit.
Joel Havens
Looks like a new store, today. They have cleared floor space and moved some things around. It is easier to move around. It actually appears brighter.
Tara Wink
Love Love LOVE this Thrift shop. It's so clean and well organized. The volunteers work so hard and it shows! I always find amazing things here!
Stephanie Gordon
I absolutely love the shop..my finds are amazing! The work that goes into taking in the donations, sorting, cleaning, pricing and then put out for shopping, the work is endless and when I learned it was all done by volunteers, my respect for them had risen to higher levels. I have seen women acting out, speaking rudely and it makes me mad that people could act like this towards the staff.
Bruce Johnson
Great place. Good stuff. Always new things there for cheap. People there are always friendly. *they they are very serious about leaving at 2:30. Don't get there at 2:25 thinking you can go shopping.
Stephen Scott
Friendly staff and great prices on good stuff I've bought alot of things from them
Marisa Pizzi
We love visiting the Old & New Thrift Shop! I’ve been taking my three children there for years and we always make sure to stop by when we are down. The staff is always so helpful and friendly and the prices are very fair. The selection is fantastic. The manager, Maddie, is wonderful and always goes out of her way to be kind to me and my children. I can’t say enough about how much we love this shop!!
Nancy Tomasso
This is in response to the post by Maple G. I frequent this store, and can honestly say everything you have said is completely false!! You obviously have a personal vendetta with this store or the staff, and are using social media to vent. The comments you have written are bordering on slander!! Perhaps you should go into the store personally to discuss any of your mythical accusations.
Barry Glickman
Ruth the cashier was So nice and informative! She made our first experience wonderful. A lot of beautiful things there.