Search by:
Cottontails Children's Consignment storefront

Cottontails Children's Consignment

4.7(48 reviews)

Address

980 Shrewsbury Ave, Tinton Falls, New Jersey, 07724

Advertisement
Contact & Hours
Monday10AM-6PM
Tuesday10AM-6PM
Wednesday10AM-6PM
Thursday10AM-7PM
Friday10AM-6PM
Saturday10AM-6PM
Sunday11AM-4PM
Location
Find Cottontails Children's Consignment on the map

Loading map...

Advertisement

Loading ad...

Customer Reviews
4.7

48 reviews

5
41
4
3
3
1
2
2
1
1
Kristin Hock

Kristin Hock

I stopped in and was browsing around. I was looking at the top shelf for books and when my eyes got to eye level, there in front of me was a Storypod for $45! Brand new is $100+. I couldn’t believe it! So grateful I found the Storypod at Cottontails for less than half the original price. My toddlers are obsessed! You never know what you’ll find there but one thing is for sure, you won’t be leaving empty handed.

Owner Response

That's such an awesome find, Kristin! Thank you so much to take the time to write this. We appreciate it more than you know! 🫶

Jenny Dahabsu

Jenny Dahabsu

Friendly and helpful staff, great collection of items. I love returning here and finding something I never would have in common clothing stores!

Owner Response

Thank you so much, Jenny, for taking the time to write this. It means so much!

Charisma Wentzel

Charisma Wentzel

Cute and organized.

Owner Response

Thank you so much, Charisma! We appreciate you taking the time to review us. And that you noticed the effort we put into keeping this place as organized as we can 🙃🤗

Melodee Peters

Melodee Peters

I’ll give it 5 stars bc I like the stuff. It’s quality consignment. But the older woman is just awful. No personality and rude. She’s lucky it’s a good store because if it based off her personality and service it would have been shut down.

Owner Response

Hi Melodee, thanks for taking the time to review us. I'm sorry you had a negative employee experience and I'd like to hear more about it. I can be best reached via IG or FB direct message. Best, Mariss

Lacey DeBoer

Lacey DeBoer

Been shopping and consiging here for 8 years. Best around! Always great prices and awesome to shop with your earned credit.

Owner Response

Thank you, Lacey! Seeing our regulars like you always brightens my day.

Bart Keller

Bart Keller

We have found a lot of things here, well curated and in great condition, including Christmas dresses. The selection seems better for younger babies, anecdotally speaking, but sizes go way up so I'll be choosing this place for many years 👍

Owner Response

Thank you, Bart! Appreciate the review. Yep, we go all the way from newborn to 14/16 and even small teen sizes, with hundreds of items going out daily.

Alison Harpootlian

Alison Harpootlian

I love this store. Any extras I need for the baby at my brother's house, I come here before going online. Great, quality items and affordable prices.

jennifer Giusti

jennifer Giusti

Love love love cottontails!!! always have anything i need for my kids! I do not even live close anymore but still make the drive to come there because they are fantastic on price and the store is so put together i can be in and out pretty quickly!

Owner Response

Hi Jennifer, this made my week. Thank you so much!

Jamie M

Jamie M

An upscale consignment shop for children's clothes and toys in good condition. I play with homeless children and often get Melissa and Doug toys at cottontails for them to enjoy.

Owner Response

Thank you, Jamie! I'm so glad you're able to find great toys to share with them! What a beautiful thing 💖

Maria Perez-Cuatzilo

Maria Perez-Cuatzilo

Very nice place Kathy was very helpful finding me some holiday wear for my boys to wear for Spirit week for school and for Christmas I will be back if I need anything else

Owner Response

Thank you for writing, Maria! I'm so glad we were able to help you out during the chaos of Spirit week. Kathy is the best!

Showing 1-10 of 48 reviews
Nearby Antique Stores
Loading nearby stores...
Advertisement

Loading ad...