Designer brands at a fraction of the retail price. I love shopping here! It's a gem

This is a great store! Huge!  You have to look in all the rooms for what they have.  What customers have to remember is, the variety of what is sold is person to what is donated to them they can’t sell what isn’t donated. I walk around in there occasionally and come out with great stuff. Always worth a look.!

Look and you shall find. Some prices are a little high ( almost the same price as a department store) - sorry.

But I do love shopping second hand and give something a second life.
God Bless all the young men and Ladies who give their time.

Great place to find great bargains all while helping local organization.

I absolutely loved it. It has great stuff to buy. Most of the stuff is 5 dollars or less. They have alot pants and shirts as well as backpacks suitcases and records.

Fun experience.  They have dressing rooms to try on your finds. Staff is friendly. Lots of clothes and accessories. Housewares and linens. Small selection of children's cloths. Nice men's clothing section and there is even a seasonal room devoted to Christmas.

Very clean and lots of beautiful things to choose from.

They have a lot of items cash only I don't know if it's everyday or certain days but the two times I've been there a special color ticket is half off

Lots of great items here. A good collection of items in excellent conditions. Mostly clothes but also miscellaneous items like housewares, paintings, CDs, shoes, hats, etc. Definitely stop by for a visit and check out what they have to offer.

First time there. Suprised at the values. Bought more than expected but love it all. Will go again soon.

It's a great thrift shop. The staff is very friendly and they do a phenomenal job at keeping all the goods organized and neatly displayed.   It's always a pleasure shopping there.

Excellent!!!!
I drive an hour and a half for this place. I visit my daughter at the same time so that I can go to this place. And the people are awesome also

I've gotten lots of good items here for reasonable prices. they have mostly clothing, but have a small selection of home and kitchen goods as well.

I got a very pretty dress that was made in India here to wear to a friend's wedding a few years ago.

Wednesdays are the "annex day", where everything in the back room is $2.

Is this place permanently closed? I sure hope not. Says so when I look it up

Friendly and have many clothes and sizes to choose from.

Reasonable prices, tag sales, clothing, bedding, shoes & housegoods.

Love going one man trash another person's treasure

Nice thrift shop, clothes are always very nice.  Great linen, blanket section.
Books are $1 for hardcover and $1 for 6 paperbacks.  Everything is very neat and organized.  They also take consignment by appointment.

Great items great prices...pink tags half off...workers great also

Ladies are efficient and extremely nice...

Big store with a nice selection of itams.

This shop helps support Community Medical Center in Toms River.

This rating is for the selection that is available in the shop.  I have purchased many things over the years

Drop off hours (for consignment or donation) are inconvenient for anyone who works.  Donation is only on Tuesdays and Thursdays.

When you ask for a donation sheet for irs, you will have to wait for a manager who will write on the slip the estimate of what the items are worth.

If you are a consigner you are expected to submit 15 items per month.  Times that by 12 months is quite a few items. New consigners are only accepted in late December, early January for the following year.

One manager is very nice.

This is my favorite place to shop for things at great prices! I've found many good household items and clothing from time to time. They only take cash though, and no returns. So be sure you really want it, before you pay for it.

It's really a hit or miss.  If you wanna spend a good penny than its great. If not than its best to wait for their bag sales.  I've gotten brand new items, with tags still, for $3 a bag at their bag sales.

It is a terrific charitable mission but the manager is a grouch and she makes negative comments to customers....maybe she is a volunteer and as the old saying goes, your help is only as good as they are paid, 😆

organized store. Some things WAY overpriced. Some staff very nice others not so much!

Last time I went there I was able to find some books and dvds I could use at the nursing home I worked at. Now, it looks very picked through and not alot of selection from housewares to clothes. I will probably pop in again after quite some time has passed to see if they've gotten a replishment of stock, otherwise its meh at best.

Staff is rude and unfriendly . 91 year old mom asked to use the bathroom in an emergency . They refused the request twice . If you like to be treated disrespectfully this is your place .

Help is very rude.    My granddaughter asked for 2 pieces of tape to secure the curtain at the dressing room.    Woman did not want to give it to her.   That’s the second time that’s happened by 2 different women.

The one woman was especially rude showing me jewelry like I was in a Tiffany shop.  These items that WE DONATE are overpriced- who the hell decides what to charge???   Then things are not rung up correctly.  She couldn't read the prices that were written on stickers. I spent over $50 on this particular day and was so insulted - treated me as though I was going to steal the USED COSTUME jewelry!  I have donated tons of things and don't need to TAKE from a thrift store or anywhere else!  Oh, and when people donate, try thanking them!!

I really hate to have to write a "bad" review but this is the WORST place I have ever consigned clothing at, and I have been to a lot of them. Shopping wise, their prices are great, selection is hit or miss but I usually walk out with something. My consigning experiece was down right awful. First, I help out at a non profit, I mentioned this to them but I am in charge of ALL consignment and have permission to receive checks. The manager was SO nasty to me saying,"I dont know who you think you are but you cant just walk in here and say you are this organization, I am NOT sending a check to YOUR house, and i need something in writing saying you are even allowed to do this" What? who even cares?? what benefit would I have to saying I am part of an organization if I'm not? I should have turned around right then and there and told this nasty lady to shove it. But I swallowed my pride because I was doing this out of the goodness of my heart. She was rude n mean the entire time I was registering. The actual appointment itself was fine, and I got that insane letter she wanted signed.... but then Im met with even MORE problems. I start getting phone calls saying my appointment time is a totally different time than the one on my card. This keeps happening over and over and I have to keep calling to be sure they didnt put me down for the wrong time. When I was on vacation I had a different girl do the appointment. Well what do you know, they screwed up her appointment time and wouldn't own up to it! I can't believe how poorly this place is run, and to yell at another non profit is shameful.

Update: wow, sorry to say I will never go here again. I called them because google said they were permanently closed in September 2017, the lady was rude and said "WE DONT HAVE A WEBSITE" and yelled at me, I tried to tell her it was google and she hung up on me. lol this place is a joke.

Second Time Around is a thrift store located in Toms River, New Jersey. This store offers a unique shopping experience with a wide variety of merchandise at fair prices. Customers describe the store as having a "huge" inventory, with shoppers needing to "look in all the rooms" to discover the full selection. The store is praised for being "clean and well-organized," providing a "superb" and "clean atmosphere" for browsing.

Reviewers highlight finding "designer brands at a fraction of the retail price," as well as a diverse range of clothing, accessories, and household items. Customers appreciate the store's mission, with one noting it's a "great place to find great bargains all while helping local organization." Another reviewer praises the "young men and Ladies who give their time" to operate the store. The overall sentiment is one of satisfaction, with phrases like "I love shopping here!" and "Is excelent" conveying the positive customer experiences.

Shoppers describe finding "great stuff to buy" and "great bargains," highlighting the store's ability to offer quality merchandise at affordable prices. Second Time Around appears to be a hidden gem in the Toms River community, providing a unique and enjoyable shopping experience for local residents.

Second Time Around

Hours

Abraham Espinoza

Alba Lucía Cano Fernández

Quanda Burks

Christina Barton

Roe Hayes

Rob Jacobs

Terryn Statham

Kathleen Planz

Rick Case

Myaashadoww