American Thrift Stores - Baldwin
Hours
Loading map...
American Thrift Stores - Baldwin is a well-regarded thrift store located in Baldwin, New York. The store is known for its impressive selection of merchandise, with one reviewer noting that it has "a larger clothing selection than Marshalls or TJ Max" and an extensive shoe and women's bag collection as well. Customers have found "really nice and quality stuff" at "amazing prices," including a "huge charcuterie board" for just $4 and a 36-inch mirror for $10.
The staff at American Thrift Stores - Baldwin are consistently praised for their exceptional customer service. Reviewers highlight the helpfulness and professionalism of specific employees, such as Nancy, the "very helpful and great" cashier, and Ms. Romero, the "great asset to your company" who is "amazingly patient" and attentive to customers' needs. One customer, Darryl Palmas, even refers to himself as the "#1 customer," indicating the strong rapport he has built with the staff.
Customers appreciate the store's organization, with one reviewer noting the "color coordination of the aisles" as being "incredibly helpful." However, they also caution that the store can get quite crowded, advising visitors to "be sure to check the closing times and know that the fitting rooms close about an hr before closing" to manage their time accordingly.
Overall, American Thrift Stores - Baldwin seems to be a hidden gem in the local community, offering a vast selection of quality merchandise at unbeatable prices, along with a dedicated and friendly staff that goes above and beyond to ensure a pleasant shopping experience for all.
50 reviews
Rogelin Degoma
Our staff cashier Nancy was very helpful and great! Keep going!
Darryl Palmas
Head cashier, Ms. Romero, Is a great asset to your company. Ive been shopping here for several years, and she has always been attentive to my shopping needs as well as super professional. She also is amazingly patient and makes me tend to spend more money than Ive intended. You guys have a great worker and super manager. I hope you appreciate her as much as I do. Sincerely, Darryl Palmas (#1 customer )
timothy kellam
I have been coming to this Thrift shop in Baldwin since it has open, I have purchased some great electronics from this location, and I picked up several musical instruments as well, i,m there at least once a week looking for Deal,s very hard working Personel always looking to help you out especially Nancy.
Audrey O'Malley
American Thrift Store is such a pleasure to shop at, and the staff that work there are always so helpful and friendly. Thank you everyone and a special thanks to Zaya who is always so welcoming, what a delight.
Ludmila Lazareva
It was my first visit and I love this place! I found really nice and quality stuff. It was not crowded on the working day.
M Rivera
I always find amazing stuff for amazing prices at this place. Staff is very helpful and very professional.
Thank you!
Amy Arndt
Great selection and really great prices for home goods. $4 for a huge charcuterie board, $10 for a 36" mirror. Will definitely come back
Thank you, Amy! Can't wait to see you again soon.
Laeana Rodriguez
i appreciate the color coordination of the aisles and hope you guys continue to do so since its incredibly helpful! Also hoping that you guys make announcements regarding closing since as.a first time visitor, I thought the store would announce closing time but I found out it was closed at closing so it was a mad dash to get to the register and figure out what I wanted to keep. So for anyone considering coming, just be sure to check the closing times and know that the fitting rooms close about an hr before closing. Manage your time accordingly so that you and the employees get out at a reasonable time. The staff here were so sweet! Thank you guys for everything today! Made my first visit here a pleasant and successful one 😊
Hi Laeana, thank you so much for the great review! We can't wait to see you again!
Tracie Thomson, Real Estate Agent
Huge store with a great variety. Many items are very well priced. Was looking for baby clothes. I like that some items are bundled in sets of 2 similar items, but a 3mth and a 9mth Pant shouldn't be paid together. Some of the pairings were not compatible, so I had to pass on a piece I liked a few times. They have a reward card as well. It's definitely worth a visit before buying new.
Thank you for your feedback Tracie!
Clifford Schaefer
This is the first store Ive seen with a larger clothing selection than Marshalls or TJ Max. Also the shoe selection as well as Womens bags were greater in selection. Just be careful with the kids. Its easy to get lost in all the rows of clothes.