Search by:
Penny Lane Antique Mall storefront

Penny Lane Antique Mall

3.7(50 reviews)

Address

319 Waterloo Geneva Rd, Geneva, New York, 14456

Contact & Hours
Monday10AM-6PM
Tuesday10AM-6PM
Wednesday10AM-6PM
Thursday10AM-6PM
Friday10AM-6PM
Saturday10AM-5PM
Sunday12-4:30PM
Location
Find Penny Lane Antique Mall on the map

Loading map...

About This Store

Penny Lane Antique Mall in Geneva, New York is a large, well-stocked antique store that offers a diverse array of vintage treasures for shoppers to discover. As one reviewer noted, "This place is big! Have found some great items for reasonable prices."

According to customer reviews, the store's inventory is extensive and eclectic, with "tons of treasures" and "a great variety of items" that can appeal to a wide range of collectors and browsers. As one customer described, "Anything you could ever want and then some!" Another reviewer elaborated, "It's a lot like a large neighborhood yard sale in a mixed socioeconomic area. There's definitely something for everyone."

Customers consistently praise the reasonable pricing at Penny Lane Antique Mall, with one noting that "the pricing was very good in our opinion." The store's "no negotiation" policy on prices seems to be appreciated by some shoppers who prefer a straightforward approach.

In terms of the shopping experience, reviewers highlight the store's large, clean facility and the helpfulness of the staff. As one customer shared, "The staff is amazing, the building is huge, and the nostalgia is beautiful." Another remarked, "Owners were very pleasant and we enjoyed looking around."

Penny Lane Antique Mall has clearly developed a loyal customer base in the local community. As one reviewer stated, "Definitely need to go back," and another expressed, "Would certainly visit again if we are in the area."

Overall, Penny Lane Antique Mall appears to be a well-regarded antique destination in Geneva, New York, offering a vast and diverse inventory of vintage items at reasonable prices in a welcoming environment.

Customer Reviews
3.7

50 reviews

5
28
4
5
3
3
2
2
1
12
Dean Wyant

Dean Wyant

Never know what you'll find. This place is big! Have found some great items for reasonable prices.

Jay Masters

Jay Masters

Great place. You never what you're going to find. I saw lots of nice stuff and some not quite nice stuff. It's a lot like a large neighborhood yard sale in a mixed socioeconomic area. There's definitely something for everyone.

Owner Response

Thanks so much!

Randy W

Randy W

Tons of treasures, at reasonable prices. A “must stop”, often 😄

Richelle G.

Richelle G.

This is such a cool place. Anything you could ever want and then some! Staff is amazing, the building is huge, and the nostalgia is beautiful.

Owner Response

Thanks so much! Grateful to hear you enjoyed your visit!

Beth Wilson

Beth Wilson

Lots to look at! Just had time for a short stop. Definitely need to go back. 2024 We finally went back and found a few neat items!

David Knight

David Knight

A great variety of items, enough to interest a vast variety of collectors looking for odds and ends

Paul Seda

Paul Seda

Loved browsing through the ended treasures

Owner Response

Thanks so much! Glad you had a fun time!!

Billie Schroder

Billie Schroder

Nice, big, clean facility. Lots of different vendors and fun things to see.

Owner Response

Thanks so much!

Jim W

Jim W

Not the Antique shop I'm used to in Pennsylvania. There were a lot of customers on the days I was there, so the rule of buying it when you see it is in effect - if you think you can go back for it, it'll probably be gone. They have more than antiques/vintage, and the pricing was very good in our opinion.

Owner Response

Thanks so much for sharing about your visit! Hope to see you again soon!

Beemer Berzins

Beemer Berzins

Went here with my family of four. Had a great time. Prices are not negotiable, but in some ways I prefer that, no games. Owners were very pleasant and we enjoyed looking around. Would certainly visit again if we are in the area.

Owner Response

Thanks so much!

Showing 1-10 of 50 reviews
Nearby Antique Stores
Loading nearby stores...