Search by:
Island Thrift storefront

Island Thrift

2.3(50 reviews)

Address

3657, 1800 NY-112, Medford, New York, 11763

Contact & Hours
Monday9:30AM-8PM
Tuesday9:30AM-8PM
Wednesday9:30AM-8PM
Thursday9:30AM-8PM
Friday9:30AM-8PM
Saturday9:30AM-8PM
Sunday10AM-7PM
Location
Find Island Thrift on the map

Loading map...

About This Store

Island Thrift is a beloved thrift store located in Medford, New York, offering a vast array of second-hand items at remarkably affordable prices. Customers rave about the store's impressive variety, with one reviewer exclaiming, "It has a lot of stuff at a cheap price! I just got a TI-84 Plus calculator at the price of $10 and it still works! I could have gotten one for the price of somewhere around $25-$150! The best!"

Shoppers consistently praise the store's organization, with one customer describing it as "well organized!" The friendly and helpful staff also contribute to the positive shopping experience, though some note that "some of the staff is friendlier than others."

The inventory at Island Thrift is truly diverse, featuring a wide range of merchandise, including books, kitchen items, and children's goods. As one customer shares, "Nice place to find second hand book and kitchen and kid stuff! Conditions are still quite good. We found an sturdy infant stool and a beautiful kid beach chair!"

Customers particularly enjoy the store's regular sales and discounts, with many raving about the "discount colors daily" and the "6 tickets color 50% off" sale on Wednesdays. One shopper exclaims, "Love this place! I go every Wednesday for the 6 tickets 50% off sale with my cousin. It's our day to hang out and find treasures. You never know what you find! Great deals!"

While the store has a loyal following, some customers note that "prices for clothing have gone up like everything else" and that "Hard to navigate, aisles narrow and children running wild." Another customer suggests that "some items are outrageous and very close to new."

Overall, Island Thrift is a beloved destination for bargain hunters in the Medford area, offering a unique and rewarding shopping experience with a vast selection of second-hand treasures at unbeatable prices.

Customer Reviews
2.3

50 reviews

5
7
4
5
3
6
2
9
1
23
Alejandra Chavez

Alejandra Chavez

When i come to Medford From Great Neck I love to stop by! It has a variety of items never leave empty handed! Staff is friendly and it is well organized!

Kristine Cascone

Kristine Cascone

Great finds, very large store, helpful & friendly staff, great prices.,,,discount colors daily, senior discount,, so much to see...... worth the trip.😃

Robin Chyna

Robin Chyna

Nice place to find second hand book and kitchen and kid stuff! Conditions are still quite good. We found an sturdy infant stool and a beautiful kid beach chair!

Ines Karamustafa

Ines Karamustafa

I always go there on Wednesday that they have 6 tickets color 50% off and I always find good deal and with the half price items come much cheaper only thing I am not agree is that the day are 50%off the staff take the items that is that day color half off they change the price or the tickets color other than that it's ok 👍

Carla Carvalhao

Carla Carvalhao

Love this place! I go every Wednesday for the 6 tickets 50% off sale with my cousin. It's our day to hang out and find treasures. You never know what you find! Great deals!

Anthony Molina

Anthony Molina

It has a lot of stuff at a cheap price! I just got a TI-84 Plus calculator at the price of $10 and it still works! I could have gotten one for the price of somewhere around $25-$150! The best!

Wendy Pepe

Wendy Pepe

Love this place. Always find brand name quality items in new or like new condition at crazy prices. Some of the staff is friendlier than others, but I guess u cant be perfect.

Britney Forbes

Britney Forbes

Big warehouse style shop. Nice stuff with discount on tag colors. Most things are very reasonably priced but some are outrageous and very close to new

Ariana LEMA

Ariana LEMA

pretty great place they have really good discounts, but sadly they don’t have much of what I’m looking for but this is the most affordable thrift store I have ever been to

Mrs Chester

Mrs Chester

Every day different color tags on sale. Prices for clothing have gone up like everything else. Hard to navigate, aisles narrow and children running wild. Staff is nice though.

Showing 1-10 of 50 reviews
Nearby Antique Stores
Loading nearby stores...