Lots of stuff, surprisingly fair prices for todays world. Kind owner

Warm atmosphere and variety is second to none!

This place is so Awesome!  They have HUGE selection and prices are absolutely amazing!! The owner and workers are so incredibly kind and I highly highly recommend checking out Milo Toys!

What a wonderful store. We could easily have spent hours there, oh wait we actually did that yesterday. Reasonable prices, amazing selection, especially the horror inventory, and the owners are super sweet. It’s where I plan to do all of my gift shopping from now on for the geeky men in my life.

If you ever want to go back in time and find toys from when you were a kid then this is the place. I've been in there several times thinking about which ones I would like to bring back into my life. At the same time bringing them into my kids' lives. If you are between 35 and 50, there's a lot from your childhood here.

Lots of vintage and classic toys with fair prices

Love this place! You walk in the shoes of your youth once again looking at toys you either had or wish you had as a kid. There is a good variety of types of toys, sports stuff, board games and action figures. Mike is such a nice guy and his wife Lauren is always nice to chat with as well!

Great store , Miko is a great guy with great deals.  Go see him for wonderful deals

Best place to look for vintage toys good place for the family

Awesome store , great selection of collectibles *****

Great place if you're looking for vintage toys and collectibles plus comics,cards, and more.

Very fun store, walked out with a treasure trove full of stuff for only $40! Will visit again

This toy shop is HUGE and so nostalgic. I saw toys in there that I forgot even existed from when I was a kid. It was fun to bring my kids in there n show them stuff. Def a must go!

I come here all the time great people always taking care and being honest with there customers love them!

If you collect vintage toys or comics, and live on Long Island, then this is the place to go.  Huge collection, always got new items, and always willimg to make a deal.  Highly recommend.

Great place to shop at for sports cards, tons of value boxes and cards. Has higher end cards too in other boxes. Good deals too

Absolutely LOVE this store. My entire childhood is in here. Everybody in the store is always welcoming and kind. ABSOLUTELY reccomend going.

Owners are very friendly! Great selection of items and prices.

This is one of my favorite places to go to as a collector. I'm always looking for little knick knacks for my studio and there are endless options here. Great for sports fanatics, throwback toys, comic collectors, Funko, Star wars, Disney, whatever your into, there's something for you. Definitely worth checking out if you're at all interested.

First time going to a shop like this in years. My dad and I absolutely love this place!! When you walk in it’s like a dream, I mean the place is incredible!! They have a crazy amount of inventory and their items are for all ages and from all different decades. They have video games, toys, comic books, vhs tapes, dvds, anything you could really imagine growing up with. The amount of vintage board games here was incredible to see!! The owners here are also super nice!! I would recommend this place to anyone, you really can’t go wrong with making this a fun stop!! We walked around for hours and you could easily spend hours here walking over and over and you still wouldn’t see everything they have. They had an amazing Disney section with all vintage items, the WWE wresting figures and the Star Wars items were just incredible to see!! We ended up walking away with some amazing figures, a Jar Jar Binks figure and some really cool Disney pins!! Can’t recommend this place enough, just walking around this store took me back to my childhood and the amount of things I saw that I had as a kid was just amazing to me. Definitely brought back some good memories, very nostalgic!!

Mike and Lauren are very nice owners they have a great wide of vintage and new toys statues pops and fairly priced highly recommend this store.

Nice staff, wide variety of video games, comics, toys, and its just fun to walk around and look at stuff

Was there today ..I sold Mike some of my  older baseball cards ..nice guy.. personable and fair..ty Mike.

Honestly this place is incredible. Not only do they have a massive inventory from everything from toys (boxed or loose), video games, comic books, movies (dvds and vhs), the owners and staff are extremely nice and make the experience of being there more enjoyable than just how awesome the inventory is. Can't recommend enough, can easily spend 2 hours there without seeing everything they have.

just bought a doll from this lovely store! service is absolutely fantastic and honestly a gem! one of the best, if not the best on long island!

Lots of toys, figures, collectibles, and records.  The owner knows his stuff, and will double check to make sure you get an honest deal if selling to him.  Prices are reasonable! If you are a Disney fan, go straight to the back (and to the left)...they have a large nostalgic disney collection and modern too.

Mike was super kind to my son. He gave us a deal on a bin of Thomas the trains and it made my 5 year olds whole day. Just pure joy, can’t thank him enough. He was also nice enough to carry to our car. Just a spectacular experience. THANK YOU.

The store is nice and large w a wide selection. The owner is super cool. I went in there a few times for MOC TMNT or older Marvel stuff and he extends deals without me even asking.

This place has SO MUCH inventory! The prices for the most part seem extremely fair.

Great little place even better people. Anything you want retro. Go give them a try you won't be sorry.

The best  place I ever visited!!! They have everything  ,you  need everything  you imagine, or dream!! It's  return  to your childhood 😊❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️I love this place . The people  are so kind and the prices is fabulous.  If you  want to fell like a child again. Come to this magical place!!!( 🤔maybe it's a 🎅 Santa's  magical work shop)😊 ✨️

I love this place!!!! They have it all. The recent expansion was a must. If you are into any.... I mean, ANY type of collectible, this is the place to go. Mike is honest and actually cares more about you and the collectible than the money. He has a customer for life.

Friendly service with an enormous collection of all types of products and collectibles.

Great toy/collectibles store.  Great stuff with friendly service.

Great owners very amazing store full of great nostalgia. They have an awesome selection of vintage goodies. Definitely highly recommend going. It's worth it!!
Thanks again

I wish I could give 10 stars. Mike and Lauren have every toy and collectible your heart desires. They run a fair business, built on kind principles. #toys #vintagetoys #barbies #Disney #collectibles

Milo Toys & Collectibles is a gem for toy enthusiasts. The diverse selection caters to all interests, making it a fantastic spot for families with kids. The owners' kindness adds to the welcoming atmosphere. A must-visit destination.

The staff is friendly and curtious. Like collectables and other fine things this place has it. Tell them Ray sent you. Just sample of what they have.

Excellent place for all sorts of collectibles,  from hot wheels,  disney, action figures, barbie, Comics , lego, vhs tapes, starwars, fisher price, GI Joe , baseball cards and so much more , come on down .  Montauk Hwy Oakdale

A great place filled with different style toys and collectibles a fun look around 👍

Cool spot with nice staff and a good selection. Reasonable prices too

Love this store. Mi and Lo are both great, friendly people.

If you're into collecting toys or comics this is definitely your store. The owners are super attentive and friendly. I been coming to this store for about 2 years now and I always get something, I mean how can I not? There's new and used toys, marvel, DC, Disney, Barbies, star wars, the Simpsons, the Lord of the rings and waaaay more, prices are reasonable. My collection has gotten bigger ever since I found this store. We drive about 50 mins so believe me when I say it's a great store.

Great place ! An awesome mish-mosh of everything!  Retro, collectables new and old toys and thing both obscure and common! A must pass through.  You won't leave empty handed !!

Terrific store! A lot of toys, games, and other collectibles at reasonable prices. Nice staff. Highly recommended!

Amazing toy store that I will definitely visit again. Tons and tons stuff. Great owner with great prices. Highly recommended for toy collectors of all ages!

Absolutely a gem of a store. Excellent selection with great prices -- plus the owners are wonderful!

Great antiques toys lots of things buy can't find the owners husband and wife will find for you there WONDERFUL people

Wonderful store for collectors of all kinds.
Mike is the excellent owner and is an absolute gentleman, is easy to deal with and you'll love going there any time.

Great place with a lot of great items for sale! The owner is very negotiable and reasonable!

Milo Toys & Collectables

Shea Jordan

Robert Rothschild

Katelyn Kelly

J Groh

Jack

Mike Sayville

Tiffany

Anthony Primerano

NOS Die-Cast

JONATHAN VELEZ