Mystery Vault
Address
650 Lee Blvd L07B, Yorktown Heights, New York, 10598
Phone
+1 914-214-8432Loading map...
The Mystery Vault is a unique collectibles store located in Yorktown Heights, New York. The store's owner, Peter, is the driving force behind its appeal. Customers describe him as "super friendly and knowledgeable about a lot of collectibles and card games," creating a "chill environment" that sets the store apart from others in the Jefferson Valley Mall.
The store's inventory caters to a wide range of collectors and enthusiasts. Reviewers mention finding "random and rare items" across various categories, including a "great Pokemon section" and a selection of Xbox 360 games. Customers consistently praise the Mystery Vault's "great customer service" and "fair prices," with one reviewer stating, "He prices are fair and he will educate you if you have questions. Highly recommend stopping by here, it's my favorite card shop in the Hudson Valley." Another customer simply declared, "This place is amazing and the guy that runs the show is a fantastic person and very knowledgeable."
With its unique inventory, knowledgeable owner, and welcoming atmosphere, the Mystery Vault offers a one-of-a-kind shopping experience for those seeking rare and interesting collectibles in the Yorktown Heights area.
12 reviews
Ari Brown
The Mystery Vault is by far, my favorite store in the Jefferson Valley Mall! Peter is super friendly and knowledgeable about a lot of collectibles and card games. He creates a chill environment in the mall that no one else has in their store. If you haven't already, check out the Mystery Vault!
Scorcher Fox
This place is awesome! The owner is a great guy and is very informative too. Great customer service, great atmosphere
Jon
Easily the best spot for TCGs. Peter is one of the nicest and informative people I have ever met. He prices are fair and he will educate you if you have questions. Highly recommend stopping by here, it's my favorite card shop in the Hudson Valley.
Tony Ricci
This place is amazing and the guy that runs the show is a fantastic person and very knowledgeable .. I would rate this place a 10/5
Arjen Weremeychik
I rarely ever rate anything 5 stars, but this guy is the man. He has so many random and rare items for such good prices and is pretty flexible. Great customer service.
Danny Norton
Never know what you’re going to find at mystery vault! There’s something there for everybody and always something new on the shelves. Love coming to the store it brings back so much nostalgia! Pete the owner is a great guy definitely stop in and chat with him about any category he is very knowledgeable across-the-board!
Dylan Ogden
I went there and got a game for the Xbox 360. Very Well priced and good selection of games. Worked no problem. Customer Service was great
Frank Dolo
They have a very nice pokemon sections and it's always a fun time going inside to rip packs. Would recommend 👌 100%
Matt Santoro
Pete was the man! Lots of great stuff and variety for a great price! Highly recommended
Ashley Higgins
Really awesome store, has a little of everything for the whole family. The owners are very helpful. Must check out!