Pickaway Craft Mall
Loading map...
Pickaway Craft Mall is a sprawling antique and craft emporium located in a former hardware store and church building in Circleville, Ohio. This expansive 15,000-square-foot shop showcases an impressive collection of vintage furniture, glassware, primitives, records, home decor, clothing, and much more, all carefully curated by owner Tara Schlichter and her knowledgeable staff.
Customers rave about the store's amazing finds and cool experience of discovering unique, one-of-a-kind pieces. The diverse inventory ranges from classic mid-century modern furnishings to handcrafted artisanal creations, ensuring there is something to delight every visitor, whether they are seasoned antique hunters or simply looking to add a touch of vintage charm to their home. The store is known for its reasonable prices and friendly, helpful staff who are eager to share their expertise and assist in finding that elusive item.
Conveniently located just off Route 23 in the heart of Circleville, the store's clean, well-organized layout allows customers to browse the diverse selection with ease, moving from room to room to explore the treasure trove of vintage and handcrafted treasures.
Beyond the store's impressive inventory, Pickaway Craft Mall is also a hub for the local community. Situated just a short drive from the historic Circleville Pumpkin Show, one of Ohio's largest and longest-running festivals, the store offers the perfect opportunity to combine antique shopping with a celebration of the region's rich cultural heritage. Visitors can also explore the charming downtown Circleville area, with its quaint shops, restaurants, and the iconic Circleville Water Tower, before or after their visit to the craft mall.
As Pickaway Craft Mall celebrates its 10th anniversary, it continues to stand out as a beloved destination for antique enthusiasts and casual shoppers alike. With its expansive selection, reasonable prices, and friendly, knowledgeable staff, the store has firmly established itself as a must-visit attraction for anyone exploring the Circleville area. Whether you're in search of the perfect vintage accent piece or simply looking to immerse yourself in the unique charm of this Ohio community, Pickaway Craft Mall is sure to delight and inspire.
50 reviews
Shannon Thomson
This place is amazing!
Lynette Stewart
This place had so many amazing finds!
Uce BREAKER92
Very cool experience with a great selection! Definitely be back in the future! 👍
Carole Irwin
I went in there to see if I could find an old biscuit cutter but came out with a new purse for $2.95! Leather too!
Mistti Osborn
Lots of cute things and friendly associates
Barb Funk
This place has now moved across the parking lot! As you turn off North Court and head downhill into the parking lot, the craft mall is on the right. It used to be part of the old Jim's Pay and Save hardware, then was a church and is now a consignment shop! Inside is a wide array of new, hand crafted, antiques, primitives, glassware, Crossroads candles and melts, vintage records and vinyl, fishing rods, cast iron, furniture, clothing, purses, braided mats, floral, repurposed and upcycled items, candles made on site, jewelry, pet products, man cave stuff and more! And when they have sales, they are FANTASTIC!!
Patricia Goffin
Staff was very friendly, they had a retry good selection, it could have been better, but I went late on a Sun so inventory was picked over. Great place go check them out!
Michelle Talbot
Lots of treasures for all tastes and reasonably priced to boot. I'll be back very soon.
Bobby Brewer
Awesome place to shop. They have a little something for everyone. The prices are very reasonable. Very clean and friendly atmosphere. A must see if your in the area. Very highly recommend.
King lion heart III
A lot of really cool items for a decent price especially at the military surplus store