What a great find.   All kinds of treasures can be found at this store.  Plenty of gently used items available for sale.   Definitely worth a look

Love the variety here. Some very nice and unique furniture. I recommend stopping in to see what's new 👍👍

Extremely friendly staff who genuinely want to help. Outstanding prices. Unique suggestions with new merchandise coming daily.

Always find very nice furniture. Clean and presentable. The older couple that run the shop are very sweet.

Love going here!! They always have something cool!

Really cool place. If you get a chance to stop by they have a wide selection of some really cool stuff with great pricing!

Nice collection of clean consignment.  Store owner Kevin is nice and helpful

Cute little shop. They have a nice variety of older furniture and decor, at a very reasonable and affordable price. Staff is very friendly as well

Found some really neat stuff for my collection

Interesting place! I've had them sell things for me and had no issues. I also have purchased some really nice things there as well. If you are in need of furniture or other household items check them out!!

Awesome place, took my two leather couches there. Long story  it wasn't  supposed  to go there but he took them anyway  cause there were to nice to send away. Kevin awesome.

Great experience, starting right at the front door! Very friendly greeting from Connie & she was very pleasant & helpful. Clean, neat & beautifully displayed articles! Absolutely loved it!

This place is amazing and the prices are excellent. The staff is also really kind. Things go quickly though- if you see something you like, snatch it up right away!

Looking through my antique items and my mothers era items was very interesting!   Most things I’ve seen before but then theres the this lid remover.

Love shopping here, good used items. Mixture of items available.

A well kept secret! Lots of great finds here and well priced. Tuesdays are discount days for medical personnel with ID.

This store has evolved.  I find some of the best vintage cookware here.  Owner is super friendly. Who doesn't like going shopping where a little dog greets you ??
Looking for lightly or unused stuff.. check this place out.

Great discounts, eclectic and beautiful antiques, some great finds!  Friendly , helpful

Absolutely fantastic place! Great selection with reasonable prices! Employees were extremely nice and very helpful!

Fantastic store! Employees were extremely nice and very helpful! The selection of items was fantastic! Prices were very reasonable!

I love this little shop! So many great treasures to be found!

This place is AMAZING!!! Their prices are so reasonable I always check there first before going anywhere else for furniture and home decor items.

I have gotten so much from this store, I should own stock!:) This is a truly unique store as well as the other Finders Keepers in the area.

Clean, spacious, and organized with a good selection. Not just furniture there's also kitchen items, some unusual hard to find things and a few antiques.

Fun place to visit. Lots of unique items I would love to take home! Amazing how many items are in this store! You definitely need to go in and browse!

Great prices, always different stock. Mike is very helpful and friendly. Fun place to shop.

Very nice store.  Everything is displayed nicely and clean.  Great bargains here!!

Second time there.. Love this store... Very nice second hand store 👍👍🖕

I love this shop, I've been going there for years and it's always fun and full of reasonably priced treasures.  The staff is super nice too, which always makes me happy.

New owners have done a great job on reorganization of inventory. Very reasonable prices.

Always unique pieces to be found!  I've done well with the items I've consigned.  The new owners are awesome.

Absolutely love this store! It's the best place for furniture, and home decor.  Ive come here for years and have yet to be disappointed.  The prices are insanely low and the items are high quality.  The staff is very friendly and helpful!

Just absolutely love this place. Great place for great used items. You are also always sure to find something interesting or unique. I have used them for much of my decorating needs. You will not be disappointed.

This place is so cool! Really nice things in excellent condition at very good prices. No pressure. Great atmosphere. Take your time.  Take a friend. Enjoy your visit!

I discovered Finders Keepers years ago when I moved to York County.  The quality and selection is amazing and prices generally lower than any other consignment stores I have found.  I have completely furnished two homes from their stores.  Absolutely love it.

Expensive overall on their furniture and accessories.

Lots of cool items in the store and the guy running the register was pretty cool and friendly

I guess this is what you would call a Hidden Gem? They have a nice eclectic Supply of vintage and non-vintage furniture and decorative items. If anything the one thing that sort of bothered me was that Items that people purchased we're still on the floor and it was disappointing when we found a set of furniture made of wine barrels and my wife really love to pretend to come to find out somebody that already purchased it. Otherwise nice place definitely keep my eyes open there.

A fun place to explore as are the other locations. This one is a bit tight to get through though. Always decent prices and fun treasures to be found.

Great experience for the most part. ..lots of great stuff. ...however customer service is not that great.

Customer service was lacking, wish he was friendlier. My friend was looking for some good deals for a move in April, nothing stood out.

Their merchandise is not what it used to be when it was across the road from where it is now,their quality has really gone down and their prices have really went up!! I won't be going there very often!!

I have found some great and reasonably priced furniture here. The customer service is maybe in decline at the moment, but don't let that deter you from looking for that perfect interesting piece. Good prices, staging, selection and quality.

It's OK... not our favorite.. we left with nothing...

Shopped here over the years. Will not go back. Owner very cocky. Overcharged me for an item. Would not show me the tag that he had removed & would not refund my money. Extremely poor customer service.

Shopped at all the Finders Keepers stores when previous owners ran it. Really nice furniture and home decor back then. Both West York and East York are now trashy. I saw broken and dirty furniture throughout. Junk store. Previous owners would have never ever accepted items like this. Won't go back anymore.

I will never give this place my business again. They do not have their act together and the one team his mouth the whole time about how horrible his partner was. Not appealing to customers and you have horrible communication between them.

Would rate it zero stars if possible. Though there are some very good finds there, the customer service and overall atmosphere severely damages the public appeal of this business. Went to the one on White dr. (I believe was the name of the street) and one of the men working the store treated me with a smug and sour attitude every time I asked a question about a buy. Then, my six year old son, as children will do, opened a cabinet on an old wooden broke down hutch or something, all wood and no glass or anything breakable mind you, and instead of approaching me, the short-fused man came right up on my child and scowled at him, "hey, keep your fingers off of the merchandise, PLEASE and THANK YOU VERY MUCH!!!"
Funny enough, his honest response was, "you're welcome" in a pitiful apologetic tone with his little head hung to the floor and his big brown puppy eyes looking up at the guy. And believe me when I say, he did nothing wrong, he wasn't running or being loud or getting into things. All he did was open a door on a cabinet that was listed at the whopping price of 15 bucks. All the guy had to do was ask me to take care of whatever he did or didn't want my child to do or not do and I would have gladly obliged, but I, or my son, wasn't given that opportunity, he took it upon himself to scold and scare my son, as this intimidating, scary, towering over him stranger.
I got angry, didn't say a word, and left. Said to myself, well, i guess it's just not a place for kids and called the other Finder's Keepers on E Prospect, as it was a bit of a drive, called ahead to see if they still had an AC my inlaws had told me they had. I had called about it earlier in the day, which was what put me in the White St. Store to begin with, but upon arrival, had realized I had went to the wrong FK, and just decided to browse around until that man did that. So I called the E Prospect one to get the model number of the AC before I made the trip, just to see if it was the one we were thinking it was. (We were already anticipating having to pay over $100 for it so we wanted to make sure it was the one we were thinking of before driving all the way there). So I called back, this man answers the phone "Can I help you"
"Is this Finders Keepers?"
"YES!" (Kinda like, DUUH!)
"Okay, was just calling about the AC I called about this morning that you guys have for sale, just wanted to--"
(Cut off with)
"Mam, we don't have any air conditioner. Sorry"
CLICK
Called back, same guy answers same tone.
"Hi, yea, it's me again, I was trying to say that you DO have an AC there I ju--"
(Cut off again)
"Mam, we have xx other locations, try one of them, maybe they have one, okay, thank you!"
And then I was a bit irritated knowing he was about to hang up again,
"WHOA, WHOA, WHOA, I'm just trying to say that I know for a FACT that it's there, i talked to another employee there this morning and they told me you still had it, said the tubing wasn't with it, and gave me the buy now price on it!!"
"(SIGH)..Hold please............"(could so hear the irritation in his tone) "Uh, yes, we do have one AC unit, I see it right here now, and its $100, okay? Thank you"
(No apology, nothing)
"Wait, wait! I know how much it is sir, I've been TRYING to ask you for the model number."
"I don't know anything about a model number mam, just that it's an LG, Okay?"
"It's on the bottom"
"UH, LOOK MISS, I SIMPLY DO NOT HAVE THE TIME TO WASTE, AND WILL NOT WASTE THE TIME, TO GO LOOKING UP MODEL NUMBERS ON MERCHANDISE ALL OVER THE STORE, OKAY?"
"Well, I'm not ASKING you to run all over the store, you have it there in eye's sight, can't you just take a peak right under the edge at the silver model number sticker?"
"NOPE! WON'T DO IT. YOU'LL JUST HAVE TO COME IN AND GET IT YOURSELF, I HAVE A JOB TO DO, OKAY? THANK YOU!!!!!"
CLICK.
And that was that.
Didn't get a chance to look at what the business had to offer itself because I couldn't get past the disgruntled, snooty, snappy employees at the stores! They won't soon get my business no matter how good the deal, I do have SOME dignity afterall!

Finders Keepers East

Nikki @TreasuredTreksTravel

J Finky

Kathleen Mclane

Lacey Womack

Christal Haley

Louise Soskin

Vinman

Michael Roberts

Dead-Head93

James Allen