Blue Mountain Thrift Store
Address
64 N Londonderry Square, Palmyra, Pennsylvania, 17078
Phone
+1 717-867-1595Website
Visit WebsiteLoading map...
The Blue Mountain Thrift Store in Palmyra, Pennsylvania is a well-regarded secondhand shop that offers a diverse selection of gently used merchandise at reasonable prices. Based on the positive customer reviews, the store is known for its clean, organized layout and friendly staff.
One reviewer raves about the "great selection of furniture" at the store, noting that "there's something for everyone there." Another customer praises the "great prices" and "great quality" of the items, describing the staff as "cool." Several reviewers highlight the store's impressive vintage and collectible offerings, with one customer finding "vintage 80's toys" for a fraction of their eBay prices.
The inventory at Blue Mountain Thrift Store caters to a wide range of interests and needs. Customers have reported finding everything from clothing and household goods to furniture and books in "very nice condition." As one reviewer notes, "even walkers, canes, furniture, stuffed animals, anything & everything!" can be found at the store.
Customers consistently praise the cleanliness and organization of the Blue Mountain Thrift Store, with one reviewer describing it as "the cleanest, most organized place I have ever been to." Another customer notes that the store has "worked hard to organize it better, and it's very clean."
While a few reviewers have expressed concerns about pricing, the majority of customers seem to feel that the store offers excellent value. As one shopper states, "the clothing prices were slightly higher than my local thrift shops but the quality and selection was much better." Another reviewer notes that the store's "prices are insanely high," but this appears to be an outlier among the overwhelmingly positive feedback.
Overall, the Blue Mountain Thrift Store in Palmyra, Pennsylvania emerges as a well-curated secondhand shop that provides customers with a diverse selection of gently used merchandise in a clean, organized environment. The store's reputation for quality, value, and customer service is evident in the enthusiastic reviews from satisfied shoppers.
50 reviews
Debby Kownacki
Store has great selection of furniture!! There’s something for everyone there. Clean store friendly staff😃⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Brandon Burke
Great prices, great quality, the workers are cool.
Barb Zornes
Their prices are insanely high and quality of merchandise has declined mensley went there yesterday and bought a pair of jeans and when i got home took notice that before i went to wear them i had to put a iron on patch on them.. I give only 3 star ratting.
Mars Hill
I am not a pro at “ thrifting “ the only comparison I really know is good will which im not a fan of .. with that said .. it is mind boggling to me how this place is getting trashed by people left and right meanwhile your average crappy restaurant / contractor in the area all have 4.5 stars What I do know is I have gotten toys for my daughter that on eBay would be 10-15 times the price for the same used vintage 80’s toys. Im not talking stuffed animals I mean those fisher price walls with a door and all the bells and whistles for literally 8 bucks. Still working audio .. so yeah I think this is ridiculous in light of what I mentioned regarding other businesses that truly don’t care and cost way more $ doing so well
LD Hack
This was the best thrift store I have been to in a long time. Great variety of clothing and the quality is good, no junky clothes here!!!!! Very clean store and the staff was so friendly. I will be shopping here more often, the hour drive is worth it!!! The clothing prices were slightly higher than my local thrift shops but the quality and selection was much better.
KevHeidi Hebert
My favorite thrift store in the area! I can tell they’ve worked hard to organize it better, and it’s very clean. They were full of awesome stuff when I stopped in today. Especially fun were all the vintage couches in great shape for only $130! I’ll definitely be back again. 😍
Ana Yes
Great finds, great prices. Went there the other day and was kind of empty but I know that it's donation based. Nice vintage items and book selection. Store was neat and tidy with employees making sure it was clean. You can find some real treasures in there!
AL Mummart
1-7-2021 Great place, nice variety! Prices very reasonable! Something for everyone! Look for the price color chart for discounts of 50%, 25% & 10% off the listed price per color of the price tag! Tuesday is Senior Discount Day- take another 10% off the color tag discount! All of their clothes seem to be very clean and in very nice condition (Gently Used)! Even walkers, canes, furniture, stuffed animals, anything & everyrhing! Last year I bought this Hutch ($60) & Mirror ($18) here, See Photos.
Bonnie Hoeger
One of the BEST thrift stores ever! Set up a pickup (and the woman who I spoke with as did the scheduling was wonderful!!!!). The people who came to do the pickup were amazing..... polite and went out of their way to carefully remove all items..... I highly recommend calling them when you wish to donate!!!! I have used them for years to donate! They also have the cleanest, most organized place I have ever been to!
Michael DeLeon
very good place. spread out, clean, well organized and great selection. the staff I interacted with were great and the prices overall were very good. great book selections, lots of woman's clothing, lots of knick knacks. some of their collectible stuff upfront was very overpriced but that's my only complaint. would go back often.