Greater Milwaukee Coin
Loading map...
Greater Milwaukee Coin is a specialty shop located in Brookfield, Wisconsin, a thriving suburb just west of Milwaukee. Established as a trusted destination for coin collectors, precious metal enthusiasts, and those seeking to buy or sell rare and valuable items, the store boasts an extensive inventory of collectible coins and numismatic treasures.
At the heart of Greater Milwaukee Coin's offerings are sought-after wheat cents, silver dollars, buffalo nickels, and mercury dimes. Customers consistently praise the store's knowledgeable staff for their expertise in providing free coin appraisals, ensuring fair and honest valuations. Whether you're looking to expand your collection or cash in on your numismatic finds, the team's dedication to exceptional customer service creates a welcoming and comfortable environment to explore your options.
Conveniently situated with ample parking and wheelchair accessibility, the store is open Monday through Saturday, with Saturday hours from 10 AM to 2 PM. Many customers have discovered rare and valuable items in the store's meticulously maintained selection, testament to the staff's commitment to curating a diverse and high-quality inventory.
Beyond its impressive numismatic offerings, Greater Milwaukee Coin is also affiliated with numerous highly credentialed business and numismatic associations, further solidifying its reputation as a trusted resource for collectors and sellers. Visitors can enjoy the charming downtown district, with its quaint boutiques, local eateries, and the Brookfield Farmers Market, held every Saturday from May to October.
For those with a passion for coins, precious metals, and the thrill of discovering rare and valuable items, Greater Milwaukee Coin is a must-visit destination. With its exceptional customer service, fair pricing, and unparalleled inventory, this specialty shop has earned a sterling reputation as a trusted resource for numismatists and collectors throughout the region.
50 reviews
Pat Roznowski
Went to get some advice on some coins I had. Place was easy to find. The room was clean and stafd friendly from the time we walked in. I felt they were very knowledgeable on the coins. I was able to sell most of them. Glad I stopped in. Plenty of parking.
Travis Kahn
Super friendly and always willing to help. Walked in the other today with some of my coins and got an appraisal right away for free. No appointment or anything, then I tried to pay for the appraisal and wouldn't let me. Great place, will be back again.
The Skin Lab Reiko Ratner
Greater Milwaukee Coin offers fair payouts, trustworthy service, and a friendly experience. My husband and I were very happy with their honest pricing for gold, silver, and rare coins, we got very fair and/or better offers compared to other local dealers. Ambrea is knowledgeable, approachable, and takes time to explain valuations, fostering trust. Their welcoming attitude makes it a go-to spot for collectors and sellers alike. Highly recommended for a reliable and pleasant transaction!
Stacey Williams
Knowledgeable, friendly, and fair
Thomas Mazzone
Went in to sell a scrap gold ring after going to several other shops around town. The girl who helped me should teach a class on customer service. Her service cannot be better. Forgot to ask her name. Greater Milwaukee Coin’s payout on gold is also much higher than other shops around. I normally don’t do reviews, but I highly recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell gold or silver coins or jewelry. Thank you.
Tyler Whipaholik (Whipaholik)
Knowledgeable, quick and easy sale!
Carter U
Love buying and selling silver/gold at this establishment. 10/10 recommend.
Troy Wallermann
Ben and the crew were super nice and honest I brought in alot of coins did everything right in front of me didn't take in back no misleading stuff also I had a wooden box thought only had one tray in it, they bought the box then called me saying there was another tray under it with a 50 dollar gold Buffalo piece and bunch 1 oz silver over 3 grand worth they could've not said anything but they told me about it and paid to me that's the people you want to deal with for the people giving poor rating maybe it's you not them.
Sandra Samolinski
Great place to build your collection
Lauren House
Excellent people. Fair prices.