St Mary's Thrift Shop
Loading map...
St Mary's Thrift Shop in Elm Grove, Wisconsin is a well-regarded community thrift store with a mission to support the local church and school. The store offers a wide variety of new and like-new items at very reasonable prices, with hidden gems galore.
The inventory includes an assortment of household goods, clothing for all ages, pets and plants, jewelry, and purses. The merchandise is exquisitely arranged and nicely laid out in the store, which is described as very clean. The shop is located in a former convent that has been converted into the thrift store.
Customers consistently praise the wonderful, helpful volunteers who staff the shop. The staff are always friendly and kind, and the store has a loyal following, with some shoppers visiting weekly to browse the ever-changing selection.
The store's mission and pricing are also highlights. The revenue from the sales of the donations from the generous community supports the local church and school. Customers note that the items are fairly priced, with sales up to 70 percent off. As one enthusiastic reviewer concluded, "What's the point in shopping anywhere else. Right?"
49 reviews
Tracy Meylor
Best thrift store! Have had sales up to 70 percent off! Not over priced! Keep up the great work that you do for others!
Sharlane Brown
The staff are helpful and kind!!
Jeanne Allen
The mission of St. Mary's Thrift shop is to support the church and school with the revenue from the sales of the donations from our generous community. We strive to fairly price the items. Please, keep in mind, we are not professionals, just volunteers that want to give back. We love our customers and the ability to help the church.
Eva Bartz
Under new management!! The shop continues to offer new and like-new items at very reasonable prices, with hidden gems galore. They are very selective for the merchandise offered; no dirty, broken, junky things. Wonderful, helpful volunteers. Many shoppers come weekly! There's lots to discover!
RedwingWanderer
Nice little thrift store
Jean Kraus
My husband and I were in the area and stopped by. Very clean, nicely laid out! This was a convent and converted into thrift shop. Volunteers were very friendly. We’ll be back if in the area again.
Melanie Zimmer
I love this wonderful store! Cool and classy merchandise, exquisitely arranged, at very reasonable prices. The staff are always friendly & helpful. Always seems to be a fun deal- yesterday it was 50% off men’s & women’s clothes to honor Veterans Day.
MaryAnn Kohlmeier
Love to shop here. It’s well organized and awesome staff who are willing to help. Wide variety from children’s, women’s and men’s, plus household goods, books and many more items.
Carol Mc Quay
What's the point in shopping anywhere else. Right? And those Stars are for Guess Who? EVERYONE! 😊. Where else can you shop these days and feel better than you did before you came? No Where! If you leave empty-handed (and I doubt that). You'll be sure to leave with a smile ☺️☺️☺️. Happy Hunting.
lynn taylor
There are a variety of items household, clothing for children and adults, pets and plans and jewelry, purses. Also tons of Christmas decorations.