Awesome Selection Of Items.  Friendly, Knowledgable Staff.  Reason Prices, Daily Special Pricing. My Very Favorite Consignment Store Ever!

Only good experiences. Seems fair and honest.

Great little consignment shop.  They have a bunch of furniture, pet supplies and kitchenware (even appliances), among other things.  Very nice layout and friendly service.

Good place to both buy and sell merchandise. Convenient to use as a reseller, there is an electronic system that tracks your current inventory as well as pricing items are selling at.

Nice thrift store with a good variety of items reasonably priced.

An impressive selection of nice furniture, and all your other consignment store favorites. They currently have a promotion on Mondays.

The store has a great selection of QUALITY merchandise. It’s laid out well and the prices are great. They even have a good selection of contemporary appliances that come with a 90 day warranty! It’s no wonder they are voted “BEST OF THE BAY”.

This is a very beat store. They have some new but mostly consigned. The store is laid out nicely and pricing is fair. No garbage there. Everything is neat and clean.

I love the new location. You could easily walk around for a while and still miss the many unique finds.

Great place to find what you want at a great price

I love Consign It !  Prices are reasonable ! Always find what I’m looking for ! Thank y’all!

Great new location, same Great stuff.  Always enjoy stopping by when we are in town.  They have some nice furniture if you are looking.

Just walking through looking at what's available,  in case we need something. Bought a cheap replacement dryer last year when waiting for parts for out new broke one.

Interesting exploring in this larger shop. They have many things.

Love Consign it!  I have to limit my trip shopping here because I always manage to find something to buy. But, the prices are so reasonable I never break the bank so...

A clean and we'll organized store compared to most resale shops. Good quality of items too.

Found many things to use and in good condition like shopping there

I’ve been a consignor and a customer. I’m extremely happy with the service I receive.  I always can find something I love when I shop at the Baypark square location or the East town location.  Recommend!!!

They always have very nice items in the store. I also Consign  my jewelry there and they are always very nice! Great staff!

Thank You for your business and review. Reviews really help small business.  Hope to see you again.

Great deal! Purchased Whirlpool washer dryer set for 1/2 retail. Only downfall was we were unable to load ourselves & delivery not included.

Nice selection of unique furniture. Friendly staff! Used their hassle-free in-house payment option.

We picked out a beautiful IKEA dining set and paid 40% less and we did not have to drive to Milwaukee to pick up.  It looks brand new and a perfect fit for our dining area.  The team at Consign It are very helpdul and the store always has beautiful quality options!  At the Bay Park Mall store, many do not know, but there is a loading and unloading area directly to the back of store so you do not have to schlep it through the mall.  I love coming here for unique buys at a great price! Love that they are open 7 days a week.

Really cool place always find some little nick nack.

Both buy and sell here. Particular about merchandise in a good way. Highly recommend.

the worker at this place was very helpful! She was very nice and the store has a variety unlike no other

I bought a gorgeous sofa last July after missing out on some other things.  If you see something you like, buy it quick because a delay of a day or two will cause you to miss it.  They are helpful and cooperative and the prices are great for the quality.

They had some really cool stuff, especially the GI Joes, which were sold at a very good price.

This place has everything. Almost too much stuff. Lol. I found what I was looking for, but for some ppl you might have to free ur mind first.

Found a neat Halloween themed electric carnival ride.

Always a fun spot to stop and look around. Never know what you may find

Thank You for taking the time to write a review.  I’m glad to hear you enjoyed your visit, hope to see you soon.

Great place, it has a little bit of everything. Lots of business for a failing mall. I'll be back!

Thank You for taking the time to write a review.  We appreciate them.  Hope to see you soon.

It's a second hand department but some of their things that are on sale are very intriguing. Found some old fishing poles and was surprised by how much it cost. Didn't buy anything today but will be coming back in the near future.

Alot of different items.  Cute stuff and a lot of furniture  and Knick knacks. Check it out.

a lot of nice things a lot of different things but I would say that they are a bit pricey although we did buy a dining room table there which is beautiful and is held up well

Probably the best consignment store I've ever been in. A wide variety, never know what you'll find there.

For a consignment shop it is very expensive but there is some very nice stuff there

This is a nice place. They use the wrong door for customer ease but oh well. Prices a little higher than most for consignment shops but quality is there. Well laid out and clean store. Didn't see any employees though. No greeting or engagement.

the staff is very helpfull.....nice selection of a varity of goods

Nice stuff but prices seem to be much higher than past.

Trying to sell Used IKEA furniture for the same price you could buy it new?

I've been there three times now, the third time being my last, for sure!

Way over priced, tired and mostly outdated inventory.

Aloof,arrogant  (about what; you run a thrift store?)counter help that don't seem to give a hoot whether you buy anything or not.

They have stuff priced above retail you can get at a place like Good Will for less than half the original price.

GO here if you want, but don't expect to find any bargains

Very unfriendly !  I Would never ever consign another piece of furniture here again . You have to keep checking to see if your consignment has sold. They will never notify you that your consignment has sold .. when you come in to get your check the girl  at the front desk barely said anything to me , no  actually she didn’t say anything to me  …so strange ……not a thank you  or hello just uncomfortable silence ….I said to the girl at the front desk you should contact us when our piece of furniture sells .. that would be great customer service . She said they sell over 100 pieces every day so there is no time for that . I said really there’s never anyone here . That really surprises me …. She just looked up at me and I left … so strange

False review:  we don’t have a fish tank or pez dispenser.  Please edit.

I don't know how it will stay open everything is crazy prices from 100 dollars for a fish tank to 50 for a pez dispenser ( everything in the store is overpriced and the workers arent very friendly they were cutting down there boss and when I would ask them to see something they would say just a minute and would go on there phone very very rude )

I am so sorry Riley.  I told you I would get back to you and I honestly dropped the ball.  Sometimes my mind is a pretzel. The bed is on display and priced at $498.

I haven't heard anything g back on a bed I inquired about over a week ago. If someone is interested,  why wouldn't you make it a priority.

I’m sorry to read your review.  We will strive to do better however I will say i will sometimes lower or remove my mask if I’m behind my counter or on the phone.  We intend to wear our masks when interacting with customers who are within 6ft of us.  Wearing a mask is important but 100% of the time is not likely.

sign on the outside of the store saying masks are required yet once inside the two people behind the counter had no masks

Thank You for your feedback. I’m sorry your experience wasn’t five star.  I hope you give us another opportunity.  I don’t know what happened, but not how we want to be.

old lady working (saturday5pm-6pm)was not only rude but I didn't even know she was the only employee there... when I asked a question about a purchase I did want,  she was sarcastic! sassy! if she wasn't so old I may have confronted her about her persona as a employee, other wise,  I'd give it a 3 maybe 4, it's a cool place for treasures, needs a cleaning,  but I sure hope the other employees are not like her..

I always come here to look everytime I'm at the east town mall and I'm usually welcomed. But a couple days ago I came and I was looking at the furniture with a friend. Everything was fine until I noticed the staff was following us everywhere we went. I thought maybe it was nothing until the man started to get extremely close to us, watching everything we did and it made us really uncomfortable. We left really fast after that. I've come here many times and gave you guys plenty of business but this kind of killed it for me. We weren't being suspicious in any way and your staff made me angry after leaving. I don't know if I'll be coming back after feeling so unwelcomed in your store.

Consign It! Consignment Gallery

Hours

Bill Van Sistine

David “Inotice.” K

Barbie Moorhouse

Elliott Kaas

Marcus Klarkowski (Marcjky)

Evan Draper

Big Wave

Al Schulz

Qiana Ehrensperger

Allen Freund