Antique Stores Near Me in Centereach, New York

Island Thrift is a large thrift store located in Centereach, New York. The store offers a diverse inventory across a wide range of categories, from jewelry and luggage to "anything you could imagine." Customers note that the store is well-organized and cleaner than most thrift stores, though some describe it as a little dingy. The layout can be congested at times, especially around the fragile items like crystal and ceramics.

Pricing at Island Thrift is a mixed bag. Some customers feel the store is overpriced, while others highlight the store's special sales and "color of the day" discounts, which allow shoppers to get something gently used and save a fortune. The customer experience also varies, with most reviewers describing the staff as kind and helpful, though one customer felt they treated people like they're there to steal. The fitting rooms can get crowded, and the checkout lines can be long, though the store will usually call for more cashiers to open registers during busy periods.

Despite these occasional challenges, Island Thrift offers a unique shopping experience for local treasure hunters. Customers never know what they will find, and it's described as the best indoor yard sale.

Savers in Centereach, New York is a well-regarded thrift store that offers a diverse selection of pre-owned goods at affordable prices. The store is known for its "great for thrift finds" across a wide range of categories, including clothes, knick-knacks, coats, artwork, and books.

Customers praise Savers' mission, noting that some of the store's profits go towards helping local charities. Shoppers are encouraged to donate items they no longer need, as the store provides a 20% in-store coupon in exchange. This sentiment is echoed by customers who appreciate how Savers "respects its customers" and "changes the narrative of what thrift means" by providing a clean, organized, and welcoming shopping experience.

Customers consistently describe Savers as "clean" and "well organized," with a spacious parking lot and helpful staff. The store is particularly praised for its great selection of books and overall cleanliness and neatness.

The general consensus is that Savers offers a positive thrifting experience, with customers expressing a desire to visit again due to the store's impressive first impression and commitment to respecting its customer base.

Overall, Savers in Centereach, New York appears to be a well-curated thrift store that provides a clean, organized, and customer-friendly shopping environment, with a diverse inventory and a mission to support local charities.